Please post your comments and/or questions. We'd appreciate any feedback regarding "The American Spirit Tower" project.

Leave your comments here.
Name:
From:
Comment:

©2002
Vision Entertainment, Inc.
All Rights Reserved

--[Recent comments]--
Sunday, August 1 at 01:38 PM:
DF from LB wrote:
"Once again, goodbye DF."

Thursday, September 11 at 07:57 PM:
penny from CA wrote:
"why did they hurt the twin tower cound,t they hurt something !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Friday, April 18 at 10:43 AM:
Matthew from J & Macerderm Building Construction INC. wrote:
"WE all know that the final blueprint is never the same from the begining, I really think the builders have incorperated beutiful features into their design...I truly hope that this design does not change dramatically, hope to share this building with my children and honor those who died on that dark and evil day"

Saturday, November 24 at 03:55 PM:
Giovann from ggbam@verizon.net wrote:
"There should be two towers. The towers should be built with solar panels; enough to provide energy to manhattan. "

Sunday, October 21 at 07:20 AM:
connor from nuneaton wrote:
"i belive in ghosts americas spirit tower isnt posted haunted because it isnt get with it.If you dont belive me make most haunted search it? "

Sunday, October 21 at 07:20 AM:
connor from nuneaton wrote:
"i belive in ghosts americas spirit tower isnt posted haunted because it isnt get with it.If you dont belive me make most haunted search it? "

Friday, September 7 at 06:45 AM:
AMSPIRIT from IDRIS wrote:
"I WANT THIS PERSON VERY WELL I LIKE TO MEET HER AND I WANT KNOW E=MAIL ADDERSS AND TELEPHONE NUMBER NOW"

Wednesday, August 8 at 01:37 PM:
tera from monica wrote:
"whats up"

Friday, June 1 at 06:16 AM:
Ashraf el Gowhary from London wrote:
"Great idea , good architecturs"

Monday, October 16 at 07:14 AM:
steve from windsor canada wrote:
"you are tounting the radical gihadists thare just going to boom it or something ,but it might be cool becouse it dose not affect me on a personl level,if thay do it it will be something to see! "

Wednesday, October 4 at 07:53 AM:
eben mans from South africa wrote:
"We have to find out more about the history of the eifel tower. Can you help? "

Friday, September 15 at 09:43 AM:
siteViva.com - Worldwide Friendship and Meeting from Worldwide wrote:
"All the folks out there, we invite you to become our member: siteViva.com - Worldwide Friendship and Meeting. With English menus, we serve people around the globe with only real (moderated) profiles. No marriage agency or fake photos on our site. Come and join, registration is free. http://www.siteviva.com "

Tuesday, September 12 at 02:27 AM:
carla from uk wrote:
"hi i think it is a grate idea and i gave a 2 min silenc yesterday 4 all opf you"

Monday, September 11 at 01:23 PM:
Fran Onjack from Chapel, NE wrote:
"I just came across this by chance on the web after doing a search on the WTC. This is beautiful! It's just the kind of thing I would hope would be built on such an important site. What happened with this proposal?? Why haven't I ever heard of this before? I hope this is what gets built."

Saturday, June 17 at 08:10 PM:
Maryam from Iran wrote:
"I want to know about the history of Eifel Tower.When it was built and why?"

"Great project and makes a statement for our country!!"

Wednesday, April 5 at 02:09 PM:
Lidia Sadlowski from Portugal wrote:
"Hello there, I would like to offer an exchange of links between your website and ours, which have excellent Google rankings. If you find such a proposal interesting then please send me details of your sites. However, if you are not interested please accept my apologies for taking your time. Best regards, Lidia Sadlowski sadlowski_lidia@o2.pl"

Tuesday, April 4 at 07:50 PM:
Alfred E. Newman from MAD wrote:
"I love cheese"

Tuesday, March 14 at 06:35 PM:
ninoshka from milwaukee wrote:
"uncle gordon i miss you"

Monday, October 10 at 02:09 PM:
Lori Stinkalot from Alabama wrote:
"Yall r just wastin' time'n money!!! Get your buts up and go help yo mama at home. You otta be ashamed of yourself waste'n money like this!!! Remember when you was poor an' couldn't afford nothin'!!!! Bye, Lori Stinkalot "

Thursday, September 8 at 12:33 PM:
Adnoris Torres from Plese post on this page: wrote:
"http://skyscraperpage.com/ I believe the addition of this structure on this page would be ,in the least, capable of furthering the imaginations of those who are interested in these sort of structures."

Thursday, August 4 at 08:52 PM:
Marcela Ferrer Moran from Butterkrust, Inc. Manila Philippines wrote:
"God is good all the time."

Thursday, August 4 at 08:47 PM:
Marcela F. Moran from Butterkrust, Inc. San Juan Metro Manila wrote:
"We must hold on to our faith. In Jesus Christ, the Lord has promised us of an eternal life with Him in the kingdom of God our Father in Heaven. Through Jesus Christ... the only way to the Lord. I invite everyone of us to please, share and spread the gospel of the Lord to all who are thristy of the word of God. Assurance of Salvation: 1 John 5:11-12 "And this is the testimony, God has given us eternal life and this life is in His Son. He who has the Son of God has life, and He who does not have the son of God does not have life." Pray for Peace on Earth."

Sunday, June 12 at 08:08 AM:
nnn from nnn wrote:
" poo poo poo poop poop poop poopy "

Friday, May 27 at 09:08 PM:
Aaron Chinn from Beaumont, TX wrote:
"Sweet design. I love the lighting concept. and hello to the other Aaron Chinn's out there. Is this the new hang out? Why didnt I get the memo?"

Tuesday, May 17 at 05:25 PM:
Rey Vallega from Manila Philippines wrote:
"How are you today Mr.Rey Vallega? Keep up."

Saturday, May 14 at 06:42 AM:
Mark Thompson from Springfield, MA wrote:
"I think it's just what the doctor ordered. Why hasn't this gotten to the media?"

Tuesday, May 10 at 01:54 PM:
E from S wrote:
"F"

Friday, May 6 at 02:00 AM:
Rey Vallega from Philippines wrote:
"How's Pentagon Tower now?"

Monday, May 2 at 08:07 AM:
miscellaneous from unknown wrote:
"No one knows how it feels until you lose a loved one. Make the best of the time you have with those you love,"

Monday, April 4 at 08:45 AM:
aftab alam from alam6464@yahoo.co.uk wrote:
"which tower replaces twin towers ( WTC )"

Wednesday, February 23 at 05:01 AM:
mohamed yousuf from india wrote:
"butiful architecture buliding"

Tuesday, February 8 at 01:23 PM:
axddc from csdasdgfnmbnbfgf wrote:
"vcxfgcvcbvvvvvvvvvvb"

Tuesday, January 25 at 10:27 PM:
Erik Khazoyan from Kent, Washington wrote:
"This proposal is simple, yet reflects the need for a balance between office space, and a memorial for those who perished on that horrible day about 3 1/2 years ago. The American Spirit Tower is the idea that will put a landmark back in the sky."

Monday, January 17 at 02:44 PM:
Bre'ana allen from long beach Cali wrote:
"what is the freakin orginal color of the statue of liberty? Can you tell me so i can get this research over with!"

Thursday, January 13 at 05:40 PM:
Todd Ford from AZ wrote:
"Well thought out and I believe this tower/monument represents what we the American people think should be done as well as tells the terrorists that they can not win like that! Thank you."

Saturday, December 18 at 07:55 AM:
waseem from india wrote:
"send invoirmebt "

Saturday, December 11 at 10:30 AM:
ghj from fgjfh wrote:
"hjgj"

Wednesday, November 24 at 03:12 AM:
cn tower from daniel thompson wrote:
"see you next year boy friend 17 barley way"

Wednesday, November 24 at 03:10 AM:
cn tower from daniel thompson wrote:
"hello cn tower this is cool im going to see you next year"

Wednesday, November 24 at 03:08 AM:
cn tower from daniel t wrote:
"hello cn tower"

Tuesday, November 9 at 09:56 PM:
Tracey from California wrote:
"wat do u think the eifel tower symbolises...is it love, happiness, anything?"

Monday, November 1 at 04:34 PM:
george from ohio wrote:
"people are having sex with the empoyees! i witnessed it myself1 i think we should stop!"

Monday, November 1 at 04:29 PM:
latsha from il wrote:
"how high is the Eifel tower? Or can you give me an estimate?"

Tuesday, September 28 at 08:03 AM:
hunter lindquist from west warren ut wrote:
"love for our country is deep deeper than the deepest deep blue sea you have got to love our country "

Monday, September 13 at 06:19 AM:
Charlene Barclay from Columbus, Ohio wrote:
"I think the project is stunning. No one is left out. "

Sunday, September 12 at 05:34 PM:
Tania from Chicago, Illinois wrote:
"I am in the eighth grade my teacher Mrs. Butler has given my class the assignment of understanding the changes our country has gone through since 911. I am glad I found your site, it helped me to deal with the lost of the twin towers. The human spirit is great, just as the American Spirit Towers will be. Thanks Tania Horace Mann School of Science and Math Technology Academy"

Tuesday, September 7 at 07:09 PM:
Adnoris Torres from East Lansing , MI wrote:
"Today I watched Frontline on PBS. It portrayed the struggle between the two groups that ended up building the new towers on the WTC site. I was disgusted by the stupidity with which the project was rebuilt. The politics, money, and egos that were behind the site were REDICULOUS! It showed the exact reasons that people look at America the way they do . It is ugly and makes no real statement. I still think this tower and idea behind it needs to become a reality. For those of you who would like to see what I am talking about please take a look at this link: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/sacred/ Again, thank you for the imagination behind this site. I still believe in this idea and hopefully , someday , it will become a reality. "

Thursday, September 2 at 11:34 PM:
ha from tae wrote:
"PANGET AKO@!!!!"

Monday, July 5 at 03:51 PM:
Larry Silverstien from Larry K Dickson wrote:
"God will see you through this... and being from Texas and a Electrician that is unemployed I would work on this project for room and board only! I love this country and will gladly offer my 27 years of experience for the cost of room and board... or a tent somewhere, My second father was a West Point Grad 1954 and I would work for free to show him my dedication to this remarkable and Respectable project! My real Father was a Teamster for 45 years in Dallas,Texas. I also owe this to Him. Larry K. Dickson Teamster Local #745 I also am A lifetime member for the cause. From Texas, God Bless New York!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Tuesday, April 27 at 10:39 AM:
EDC from New York wrote:
"I believe that."

Monday, April 5 at 09:22 PM:
melisa santos from calexico california wrote:
"I think that the way that you guys live is very cool! And I am doing a school project on my school WILLIE MORENO and i think that i am going to get a good grade because i did the right choice about choosing NEW YORK! BY: MELISA SANTOS"

Wednesday, February 11 at 10:59 PM:
Erik from Milwaukee, Wisconsin wrote:
"It is a great idea and I support it 100%. Not only is the height symbolic to American history, but the architecture with the no shadows on 9-11 is not only ingenious but an excellent way to add a little extra something to comemorate those who died not only on 9-11 but also in the '90's as well, in addition to a memorial somewhere else on grounds. The buildings will be beautiful, and New York will once again rise to show the world you can take down buildings, but you can't take down America, we will only grow stonger, and build taller. ~Erik~"

Monday, February 9 at 03:01 PM:
Aaron Chinn from UK, England wrote:
"just wanted to say hi to another person named Aaron Chinn. its great to no there is more than 1 of me hehe"

Wednesday, February 4 at 01:05 AM:
Quentin Ruth from Page Arizona wrote:
"hey all, i know its been 3 years since the twins went down but i still feel bad about all those lives has ended from it, i just want to give my love to those who lost their loved ones for all races, blacks, whites, whatever else, i remember every september of how i felt about it cause my birthday is 3 days after it, the 14th of september, well anyways, love to all that lost their loved ones, my msn messenger addy is qbear15@hotmail.com if you all wanna add me to your list"

Friday, January 23 at 08:47 AM:
Charles Seaton from C.R.Seaton Co.,Inc. Arizona wrote:
"The proposed towers are joke, they should build a three towers building with their back to each other,trianle . The back would be stright up and down but the front would be tapered in toward the top. This would have acess from each tower,at the top to the other so in case of a fire there would be an exscape for the top floor people. the center of the building at the top would extend upward 300'400' taller to make the tallest building in the world. The most inportant part would be they ,3 towers, simballize the tree branches of Goverment that the teroist were trying to destroy. Live and work in a safe invoirment. Chuck Seaton"

Wednesday, December 31 at 09:49 PM:
amit ahuja from india wrote:
"i wanted to know about history of eifel tower and fashion forecasting of haute couture bcoz i make a project "

Wednesday, December 31 at 09:47 PM:
amit ahuja from india wrote:
"i wanted to know about history of eifel tower and fashion forecasting of haute couture bcoz i make a project "

Monday, December 22 at 02:39 PM:
Tyler from Ohio, sesshomaru8173@yahoo.com wrote:
"As I said before, after looking at all the comments I think you are all ignorant. Never once did any of you actually look to see the statistics of the worlds tallest structures. The CN Tower reigns as tallest."

Monday, December 22 at 02:33 PM:
Unkown Person from OhioVicinity wrote:
"The Freedom tower is, if planned and will reach estimated hight, not the tallest building. The CN Tower is the "tallest, free-standing structure" at 1,815 ft. The Freedom Tower will be 1,776. Anyone see a difference? Because now in the news they are saying it will be the "worlds tallest building period" which is wrong in several different areas."

Friday, December 19 at 12:24 PM:
RYAN ZARNOWSKI from NEW JERSEY wrote:
"Yes hello, who can I speak with regarding plans for the entire site? My comments are worth much more than this outlet. ryanzarnowski@msn.com thank you"

Friday, December 19 at 10:26 AM:
monique Bobbitt from chicago, IL wrote:
"i wanted info on how to get funding for redeloveping low income communiity. If you can help please e-mail me @ mikya222000@yahoo.com. thank you!"

Monday, November 17 at 03:05 PM:
John T. Gallo from New York, N.Y. wrote:
"Out of all proposals for what should be done with ground zero, yours is the best and makes at lot of sense. Given the seriousness of the attack on the United States of America and the many lives lost and never recovered, this is sacred ground. Your memorial to those lives lost will be eternal. We should do no less that that !!! I do not agree that commercial buildings should be part of the memorial. This is sacred ground and to do so would violate all those who died in the twin towers. This plan should be promoted thru the various media in NYC to eliminate those ugly and offensive ideas and plans that they are trying to push on us in the name of a lasting memorial. It is time for us to do what is right and forget the idea of the almighty buck and real estate values !!! "

Sunday, October 19 at 04:08 PM:
yo mama! from Yo mama, ca wrote:
"yeah......whatever!!! who cares? the two towers arnt there now and if we build something there agian, some stupid country who is mad at us for being rich white spoiled people will knock it down!!!"

Wednesday, July 23 at 12:10 PM:
Peggy Kulbe from a downtowner worker wrote:
"I love it . . .I wish I saw this sooner. I love the simplicity and the respect it gives to all. And I love the one tall tower . . . terrific job."

Thursday, July 3 at 06:43 PM:
Robert Kaufman from Midland City, Il wrote:
"I came across your site in a search and got really inspired by your project. Why isn't this being built? What's the status of it, is it still in consideration? Good luck. I think your design really says it all."

Friday, June 13 at 08:17 AM:
you rock from you wrote:
"you stink"

Wednesday, May 7 at 07:29 AM:
john from boston wrote:
"sweet cite im moved "

Tuesday, April 8 at 07:50 AM:
Perry Villanueva from New York wrote:
"I like your design for the AST; however, I think it should be practical tower. In other words, it should be a multi-purpose skyscraper that combines both office and retail elements. This is not Paris but New York City. Buildings should always be practical especially in lower Manhattan. Too bad your design was not chosen for the WTC site but why not put it in Queens - like in Long Island City. That would help revitalized that neighborhood. "

Tuesday, March 4 at 04:59 PM:
Peter from Massachusetts wrote:
"The tower is very original and symbolic. I think it will take time for it to grow on New Yorkers and the rest of the country."

Tuesday, February 18 at 12:19 PM:
Brian Graifman from BGraifman@gkblaw.com wrote:
"As I've stated before, I lost my younger brother David at the WTC on 9-11. I'm sorry to see recent irresponsible negative comments defiling your comment board. Your design still reigns as the best and most inspiring imaginable to save the aesthetic soul of our city. "

Monday, February 17 at 07:07 PM:
Yechiel from sad wrote:
"Your proposal stinks. the world would like the tallet towers to be office towers. DO YOU HEAR ME? YES OR NO?"

Saturday, February 15 at 05:02 PM:
Wouldnt you like to know from CA; San Diego wrote:
" You seem to have a lot of fans but i have heard bad things about you so im not even going to look at this sit. Buh Bye"

Saturday, February 15 at 04:59 PM:
Disapointed from California wrote:
"I needed to find a picture of the Lincoln Momorial so i looked all over and you didnt help at all!!! I couldnt find anything on this stupid web site!!! Well i hate you!Good Bye"

Saturday, February 15 at 04:54 PM:
i dont like you! from who do you think? wrote:
"i dont like you!"

Friday, February 7 at 06:56 AM:
Jeff Venturella from NJ/NY wrote:
"Oh well. Nice try. Not that the fat lady has sung just yet....but her vocal courds seem to be warmed up. I can't see how...within the next few days this can get through...perhaps the silver lining is "Memorial". The two selected designs make way for a memorial..but I believe none is specific. Since they say that Neither of the two designs will be/look exactly as "invisioned" I can only hope during the memorial submissions...you can get this Thought/theme to the LMDC. Good luck as always.......Still a chance..small but a chance none the less "

Tuesday, February 4 at 09:27 PM:
Roberto Gomez from Irvington, NJ wrote:
"Your tower inspires me. Somehow when I look at it I feel a breath of relief. It's perfect, absolutely perfect! What can I do to help?"

Tuesday, February 4 at 08:20 PM:
Buster W. Altair from New York City wrote:
"Are you serious? This proposal is terrible. You have flattened out the gracefully rising to crescendo lower Manhattan skyline with a single addition of an comical attenuated priapus mocking the strength and energy of New York. "

Saturday, February 1 at 08:00 PM:
Aaron Chinn from Buffalo, NY wrote:
"Why isn't the American Spirit Tower listed by the city as one of the proposed plans? I think this design is the best I've seen yet. Best of luck, I hope to see it on the skyline one day."

Friday, January 31 at 08:23 AM:
amanda from lilbaby_blue_2004@yahoo.com wrote:
"hello i am a student at claymont high school. i am doing a project on how humans are effected by daylight and nightime, i am having some problems on my project and i am wondering if you can help me out with that."

Wednesday, January 22 at 06:41 PM:
Richard Loeser from Nyack, New York wrote:
"I personally watched the Twin Towers built originally and they obviously made me proud to be a New Yorker. It's my belief that all the plans to reconstruct the Worl trade Center fall short unless the final decision is made to rebuild them as the tallest buildings in the World. It's beyond my belief that The United States of America doesn't have the technological advances to rebuild in a way tha twould be terrorist proof. Again it's my belief that intelligence will win over agression! GOD BLESS AMERICA!"

Tuesday, January 21 at 11:24 AM:
Sheryl Draizen from New York wrote:
"I live about 5 blocks from Ground Zero and could not imagine having to look out my window and see any of the official designs that have been submitted. You must find a way to put your models on show in a public place and get coverage so that the LMDC will open this project up to more creative minds like yours. Let us know how we can help get this out in the public."

Tuesday, January 21 at 07:52 AM:
Jeff Venturella from New Jersey via Yonkers, New York City wrote:
"Larry - heard you on the Radio this morning...CBS _880, sounds like your pushing the plan. I have sent emails and letters on behalf of the project to Mayor and LMDC. If they have introduced a 8th plan based on Antonio Gaudi's design...then I can't imagine they will not take a formal look at this design. I will keep telling those I know.....about the design. In my eyes - it is the closest chance of having the true memory and appearance permenately re-established, if you know what I mean. Peace and good luck."

Friday, January 17 at 04:49 AM:
Gary Marinese from New Jersey wrote:
"Thank you . How come we have not seen your design presented to the public. It is the best."

Friday, January 17 at 04:47 AM:
Gary from Gary Marinese wrote:
"This caputers the true american spirit and also gives us all a memorial for all of us to visit and reflect. Thank you. "

Thursday, January 9 at 11:56 PM:
Dan from St. Louis wrote:
"I wasn't expecting to like this.... but I think I do. Very well thought out, good luck with it."

Friday, December 27 at 01:37 PM:
larry from dolores -lbhs class of 81 wrote:
"great job - very touching ideas."

Tuesday, December 24 at 12:07 PM:
Max from New City, NY wrote:
"Get the AST more exposure! It will never become a reality if you just keep it on this website! Get a commercial! Do you realize how many New Yorkers (let alone Americans) watch TV, and how many are disappointed by these hilarious new 7 proposals? Get the AST out there. Get people talking about it. Get the LMDC talking about it. The AST can become a reality, and a commercial (and more ads like the one in the NY Times) are the vehicles for making it one. "

Friday, December 20 at 01:43 PM:
Larry Russo from LMR@AmericanSpiritTower.org wrote:
"A few members on the LMDC are aware of the American Spirit Tower, but the process they structured doesn't allow for an outside proposal at this point. As a result, although the response has been overwhelmingly positive, the AST is not currently under consideration by the powers that be. If you feel it should be, please help by spreading the word. Go to the "How can I help?" section and let them know. Thanks-"

Friday, December 20 at 01:39 PM:
Brian Graifman from BGraifman@gkblaw.com wrote:
"Your tower is still the best by far - towers over the other designs. Not only am I disappointed by the 7 other designs just revealed, but I am disappointed to have read nothing about your AST design during this period. I lost my brother David in Tower 2 on 9/11. "

Friday, December 20 at 05:25 AM:
Rob from NJ wrote:
"I am one of the few that believe the entire site should become a memorial. I am also a realist and know that in the end the almighty dollar will win out. That being said, I find your your model to be the most inspiring of anything that has been suggested so far. One question, does the P.A. and the LMDC know about this idea?"

Wednesday, December 18 at 12:44 PM:
MIchael from NJ wrote:
"One suggestion (for the website): I noticed that you have redesigned the look of the office buildings around the AST in the updated images. You might want to update the primary Image Gallery so people would see these new designs."

Wednesday, December 18 at 12:37 PM:
Michael from NJ wrote:
"Just saw the 7 new designs at cnn.com. To me, none of them can even compare to the AST. Like so many people have wrote here, this is what people are looking for. As many are for rebuilding the 2 towers and many against it, the AST offers a creative compromise by honoring the footprint. The memorial and the sun-effect is well thought out. The AST is by far the best design out there. Why is it not in one of the new proposals? How do we get the AST submitted for consideration? Echoing Richard Kenderian's comment (Nov. 4), the AST may be too "thin" to be noticable from outside of Manhattan. If somehow it can be made more noticable from a distance while preserving the elegant design, this is the perfect proposal!"

Wednesday, December 18 at 11:46 AM:
Adnoris Torres from East Lansing , Michigan wrote:
"Today they unveiled the 7 WTC plans that they are planning on building and I have to say that NONE are are beautiful and majestic as your design. My father was in New York back when the original towers were built. I spoke to him from my collage dorm room on the day of the tragedy and you could feel the loss in his heart as the towers collapsed. It was a very sad day for my family and my father has been effcted ever since. When I saw this web page there was a sense of wonder and renewal in my heart . This design should be the one that is put up . I don't know what will go up in the site that is beign proposed, but I wish you all of the luck in the world and I hope that this design is the one that I will one day look up at with the same admiration my father saw when he looked up at the original two . "

Monday, December 16 at 02:39 AM:
Regan MacBannon from New York wrote:
"I like the fact that you replicated the design on the original gothic lobby. I like that alot and thank yo for it. I also assume you smartly would reinstate the elegant floor toceiling windows. I don't care for a pyramid because it is too close to replicating the vulgarity of San Francisco and this looks more like a syringe than a building. Personally Northy adn Southy should go back up or leave the site the hell alone. Anything else is a mockery of their lives and deaths. I wish people would quit being so fucking gutless. The TWIN TOWERS were the epitome of the American Spirit. You CANNOT PERFECT PERFECTION, PERIOD"

Wednesday, December 4 at 10:44 AM:
josh from new york city wrote:
"aahh its ok but i think you still need to build two towers alike but much taller then the original and put the tallest building back into the greatest city in the world nw york city but yes it is a very nice momorial but there should also be two tall buildings some where in there."

Saturday, November 23 at 10:42 AM:
peter jockel from montreal canada wrote:
"this is a beautiful and touching honour. i think it wonderful that so much space has been reserved for tribute. while commerce is important, nothing can repay the sacrifice, so this memorial puts things in a wonderful perspective.fountains and discrete night lighting will make this a fitting honour.thank you"

Friday, November 22 at 10:03 AM:
Jeff V from New York City wrote:
"So, I understand that the LMDC has chosen seven new designs to present for the Rebuilding of the "Trade Center" area. Has the American Spirit Tower been chosen as one of them? OR must we wait to hear. Any input, since I have been a great fan of your concept since first seeing it last month."

Friday, November 22 at 05:07 AM:
Anthony J. Calio, M.D. from acalio@winthrop.org. wrote:
"Great concept-start building it!"

Wednesday, November 20 at 05:45 PM:
BPS from an engineer perspective wrote:
"I think the design is magnificent! It is by far the best design I have seen to date. It is the perfect pairing of rememberance, economics, power and freedom. This is exactly what NYC needs. This isn't called the "Greatest City in the World" for nothing. Being that it is the greatest city we need something to sybolize that strength, power and freedom. Building the tallest, greatest, most breath-taking structure in the world will surely demonstrate this nation's strength. Spread the word -- this design is a winner in my books ..."

Wednesday, November 20 at 03:22 PM:
Ralph Beck from Centereach, New York wrote:
"I think this is more of what people are looking for to replace the towers. All the other architectural renditions that were submitted were too 'blah'. This is definitely an 'original', and I think is what the area needs, more in the way of a memorial, instead of just 'business buildings' and 'retail square footage'"

Tuesday, November 19 at 10:36 AM:
Mark from New York wrote:
"Over all I it’s a wonderful idea and a unique way to let the world know how NYC was effected. The AST dose a near-perfect job relating to the WTC and showing what was, But how does the AST relate to what happened in Pennsylvania and to the Pentagon? On 9/11 more then two plans crashed and NYC was not the only city that cried."

Sunday, November 17 at 01:22 PM:
Lawrence Russo from LMR@americanspirittower.org wrote:
"Sheila, The info is there- The reflective pools cover the area of the original footprints- therefore they are 1 acre in size each. The height of the tower is stated as 2200 feet tall (the office buildings can vary from 40-70 stories). As far as the golden rule as you quote it...I couldn't disagree with you more."

Sunday, November 17 at 06:20 AM:
Sheila from NYC wrote:
"Without specifics, it's difficult to make comments, e.g. how large are the reflective pools? How high are the buildings? The spire? At this point, we are still so close to 9/11 that emotion is guiding us. Since so much of lower Manhattan depended on the WTC for it's income, we need to focus on that impact. Housing, the small stores and the coffee shops all relied on this complex. And then there's the bottom line . . . the golden rule. S/he who has the gold, rules. Whoever is funding the project, determines the design."

Friday, November 15 at 07:59 AM:
Peter Stein from Eldridge Park, NJ wrote:
"This is just what I was hoping for. It's like you read my mind. This is definitely what should get built. Best of luck with it. "

Tuesday, November 12 at 08:06 AM:
Joe Van Winkle from Saddle Brook, NJ wrote:
"I believe this to be a wonderful idea; let's hope that it comes to fruition!!"

Monday, November 11 at 03:46 PM:
Jonathan S Butry from Pittsburgh, PA wrote:
"I love the design and the layut of the site. It really lives up to the billing "BALANCE." However, the name seems a bit sappy and gaudy. I think something simpler might work much better. "The American Tower," "The Tower of Rememberance" or maybe just "The Tower" are some decent ideas I have thought of."

Saturday, November 9 at 04:33 PM:
bb from new york wrote:
"Better than any I've seen"

Thursday, November 7 at 08:25 AM:
Jill from Rhode Island wrote:
"This is by far the most well thought out and approriate memorial I have seen so far. I was truly brought to tears. I honestly hope that this becomes a reality."

Thursday, November 7 at 07:30 AM:
Amanda from New Jersey wrote:
"I was absolutely moved by this project. It is the only structure I have seen thus far that could possibly replace the World Trade towers while remembering the people who lost their lives and at the same time honoring the heroes, and replacing the gaping hole where the towers used to stand. I love how it incorpartes likenesses of the original buildings & yet is different. I pray this becames a reality, it would really help to ease my sorrows over that trajic day."

Tuesday, November 5 at 08:26 PM:
Kristina Primiano from Manhattan wrote:
"wow! This is amazing! It is something that may eventually bring peace to New York City!!!!!"

Tuesday, November 5 at 11:29 AM:
Christina from NY wrote:
"I think this is a very classy project and one that comes close to what the WTC towers represented for us. It makes me proud and it also gives me a sense of dedication to the ones that were heroes that day. Congratulations!"

Tuesday, November 5 at 07:03 AM:
Barry Lieberman from Storage America wrote:
"Magnificent. I hope this becomes a reality. Barry Lieberman Barry@storageamerica.com"

Monday, November 4 at 05:54 AM:
Richard Kenderian, PE,PP from rkenderian@kzaeng.com wrote:
"Absolutly the right idea but I believe the tower needs slightly more mass so that it is visable from a greater distance and makes more of a visual impact. Although the orig. towers were architectually un-notable, the sheer mass made them impressive and created substantial impact."

Saturday, November 2 at 07:10 PM:
Kip Veasey from New York wrote:
"This is exactly the kind of thing I envisioned when the memorial talk started. You guys nailed it."

Saturday, November 2 at 08:49 AM:
Abe Granderson from AJDallas44@aol.com wrote:
"If it was up to me, I'd rebuild both towers twice as high as before. But yielding to commercial viability, I must say the American Spirit Idea is a fantastic yet pragmatic idea. I believe that a memorial tower will restore the skyline, while mooting the issue of commercial viability. People from around the world will flock to this tower's observatories, and will not hesitate to go up to the top for a 20-minute visit. "

Thursday, October 31 at 06:48 PM:
DAVID COLETTI from a member of law enforcement wrote:
"Outstanding concept and rendering. The best of all competeing viewpoints, and finally, a real tribute to both those lost, and the grand vision that built the WTC. Your concept is not mere office space, nor soley a depressing memorial. The AST is a grand design, a new achievement, which is exactly what the WTC site deserves. "

Thursday, October 31 at 12:04 PM:
Steven from New York wrote:
"This is the best design i have seen, i really feel this should be built...When i first saw this i said somebody has finally gotten it right."

Thursday, October 31 at 05:54 AM:
S. Marcoux from Rockland wrote:
"I think the American Spirit Tower is incredible. It seems to combine the right amount of reverence, respect and honor"

Wednesday, October 30 at 09:45 PM:
Kathy from Queens wrote:
"i was against them rebuilding anything in that spot, but this tribute looks like a promising idea."

Wednesday, October 30 at 09:44 PM:
F. Gallagher from NY City wrote:
"Incredible. My heartfelt wishes that your inspiring plan will be nothing less than the entire basis of the final result. "

Wednesday, October 30 at 07:51 PM:
Kasey from Staten Island wrote:
"This proposal is the best so far...it honors those who perished and the life of the building."

Wednesday, October 30 at 01:05 PM:
wariooooo from italy wrote:
"i love the plannnn"

Wednesday, October 30 at 01:04 PM:
bob from ny wrote:
"maybe not a 110% but100%"

Wednesday, October 30 at 01:03 PM:
Mariano D'Alessandro from Mariano D'Alessandro wrote:
" i support this plan 110% "

Wednesday, October 30 at 12:59 PM:
James from new york wrote:
"I am a victim of the 9/11 attacks and i support this plan for the reconstruction"

Wednesday, October 30 at 05:44 AM:
Robert J. Guadagno from Butler, NJ wrote:
"As a former worker (IT STAFFING/THINK PATH) at the WTC, I find this project to be one of the best to not only honor those lost, but to honor the two towers that we will all deeply miss. Although, it would be nice to have "smaller" office buildings around the AST... Then again, I'm not a designer... Well done! RJG"

Tuesday, October 29 at 05:57 PM:
Jim from Queens, NYC wrote:
"Great proposal, great ideas, great visions. It's the best proposal I've seen yet."

Tuesday, October 29 at 03:00 PM:
Virginia Paradise-Zitani from Ocean Twp., N.J. wrote:
"This is the best proposal I have seen yet. This is what they should put at that site."

Tuesday, October 29 at 12:54 PM:
Mike Schnall from Staten Island, NY wrote:
"I love the design. It truly captures what I've pictured in my head of illuminating the victim's names, a shining top of a tower that acts as a beckon of freedom, and a symbol that stands above all else in NYC. I also like how it ties in the footprints of the towers and leads the eye right to the sky... as if the tower will serve as a conduit to heaven. The tower also stands as a bridge to the stars and as a symbol of the intrepid American spirit to dream ever bigger, reach ever higher, and soar ever farther."

Tuesday, October 29 at 10:17 AM:
Nestor Hernandez from Massapequa, NY wrote:
"This is a very creative use of the space. It is a design that conveys all of the feelings of most americans towards 9/11 and demonstrates the indominable spirit of the american people. At the same time it provides useful space for commerce which is an integral part of our philosophy."

Tuesday, October 29 at 09:33 AM:
Laura from larry's teenage hood wrote:
"larry, i like it, i looks nice. good luck!"

Tuesday, October 29 at 08:06 AM:
Stan Boren from Burke, VA 22015 wrote:
"I like the look of this tower. I also think it would be a "fitting memorial" if you could calculate what the shadow of the twin towers was on 9/11 at that hour of the morning and "create" the look of that shadow with a darker color of ground material to provide that shadow on the ground surface area in memory of those who died there. Perhaps a black granite that could have their names carved into it."

Monday, October 28 at 09:39 PM:
Christian Zitani from Ocean Twp., N.J. wrote:
"This is by far the best proposal I have seen. I think we should have something that will be so magnificent such as this proposal. Make this our 9/11 Memorial! "

Monday, October 28 at 06:55 PM:
matt hudson from hicksville long island wrote:
"i think the project is a great idea, however i do feel that the buildings in the back are a little plain. i think they have to nbe a little taller and maybe spread throughout the park. with better designs, that are not to dramatic the site would fit better in the skyline. you may also need to add a hotel which would replace the old one in the financial center. the hotel could be of intricate design, and it could be placed in the park. i do however like the fact that bigger is better, and thats what nyc needs"

Monday, October 28 at 10:28 AM:
Len Katz from jokerschild.com wrote:
"This, by far, is the best and only replacement/memorial/landmark that has any spirit or thought involved. Having been to the top of the WTC many times, I think having a memorial that soars even higher is as wonderful a thought as can be realized. Sign me up."

Monday, October 28 at 09:05 AM:
Stephanie from Greenwich, Connecticut wrote:
"The best design yet!"

Monday, October 28 at 04:38 AM:
james C from NEW JERSEY wrote:
"I JUST HAVE THREE WORDS. I LOVE IT!!!!"

Sunday, October 27 at 10:48 PM:
Orlando Gaffney from Loryale@aol.com (Long Island NY) wrote:
"If that wonderful tower is built I want me and my wife and kids to be one of the first to go to the top and stay for a while. That is the best idea I seen yet although I haven't seen the original 6 runners up idea for the project. I don't believe that even you can top your own idea, for your tower covers everything from 9/11 to a majar comeback of the american spirit, enginenuity and creativity. If I owned that property and had Bill Gates money, you and America would have that tower just as you planed it. It can't be beat!"

Sunday, October 27 at 05:47 PM:
The Powers That Be from Mary wrote:
"Cold. Sterile. Disappointing. How do the families of the victims and the heroes feel about this tower? The cross found at Ground Zero conveyed all sorts of emotions and it was only a left-over piece of steel from the debris. Realizing the religious significance of the cross might offend some, I'm sure something else equally meaningful can be found to give a sense solace and comfort to the world. Please go back to the drawing board. Thanks for your time. "

Sunday, October 27 at 02:19 PM:
MW from NJ wrote:
"Impressive, much better than any other ideas I have seen. Incorporates all of the elements I would like to see represented."

Sunday, October 27 at 12:08 PM:
Joe Manion from Cranston, RI wrote:
"Interesting! I like it."

Sunday, October 27 at 10:21 AM:
Steve Bergman from steveberg@erols.com wrote:
"Hi - I think it looks marvelous. How many square feet of office and shopping exist in your plan versus what was there before 9/11? steveberg@erols.com"

Sunday, October 27 at 08:43 AM:
Miguel Oliveras Jr. from Long Island, New York wrote:
"By far the best idea to represent all interests"

Sunday, October 27 at 05:35 AM:
Chris Kozicki from USA wrote:
"This is close to my personal idea that the eastern 8 acres of the WTC be rededicated to office/commercial space and that the western 7 acres remain sacred ground. The spire is simple and clean, bold in its proposed height, and tastefully incorporates elements of the Towers' facade. Although I still hold that nothing should touch or lay over any portion of the Tower bases, even the sides, as in the case of AmSpirit, I sense that you have something here - something for every thinking, sentient being. Blessings in your endeavors."

Sunday, October 27 at 05:27 AM:
Michael De Giglio from Scarsdale, NY wrote:
"I lost 5 customers, all good people in the 9/11 tragedy. Your tower is a fantastic and tastful tribute. I would say the office buildings in the backround however lack character. Back to the drawing board for them. But overall (Tower, Park, Reflecting Pools, Museum, etc) well done."

Sunday, October 27 at 03:35 AM:
Josef Zuelch from Bensalem Pa wrote:
"I'll have to admit that this design is better than some of the "primary memorial" ones that I've seen. I can appreciate the architecture in The American Spirit Tower, and it's certainly a beautiful building. I don't particularly like the positioning of the four office buildings, or the short height of the four of them. How about combining the four into two tall office buildings, along with the American Spirit Tower? I think this will help bring back what was lost on 9-11, and will include something "new" showing that we've moved on and improved as a nation. It seems like the positioning, and overall design of the office buildings was an afterthought, and I think with a little more thought placed on the office buildings, and their height you would have an incrediable replacement to what we lost."

Saturday, October 26 at 03:29 PM:
R. Colton from chatul@cwnet.com wrote:
"The original World Trade Towerer were two of the ugliest building ever built. In addition the did not fit into the downtown area which still constists of interesting if not butiful buildings from pre WW11. It is a shame that architectural schools either ignore the fact that there can and should be beauty in buildings, or pass those who cannot or will not design interesting buildings."

Friday, October 25 at 08:15 PM:
Lina E from Toms River wrote:
"I miss the towers and what the stood for so badly, I need to see THIS from the turnpike as I head into the city! I truly hope they listen! Good Luck!"

Friday, October 25 at 08:13 PM:
Adam from New York wrote:
"The American Spirit Tower is the most inspired and appropriate idea for the WTC site I have seen so far. I am galled by the timid plans for rebuilding the New York skyline. While I don't expect anyone to want to work in a 110-story office building, I think we have no alternative but to build something grandiose on the site. Thanks."

Friday, October 25 at 08:07 PM:
William & Ali Chellis from Seymour, CT wrote:
"This is so beautiful. Your concept is exactly what should be erected on that hallowed ground."

Friday, October 25 at 08:07 PM:
Todd E from Zarios wrote:
"YOU drew exactly what I had in Mind!!! It must be this! Go get em!!!!!!!!"

Friday, October 25 at 06:54 PM:
Joe B. from Con Edison wrote:
"I think it's a great idea! GO FOR IT!"

Friday, October 25 at 05:15 PM:
Howard Katz from New York City wrote:
"Brilliant!!!"

Friday, October 25 at 04:54 PM:
Ray Olsen from Nazareth, Pa. wrote:
"Fantastic, a very fitting memorial for the victims of 9/11 and a distinct sign of strength for our country. A place where I would be honored to vist."

Friday, October 25 at 04:40 PM:
Paul Fitzgerald from Matawan NJ wrote:
"I think that this is a really beautiful tribute to 9/11. I knew some and some were from my Church and some were friends of my children - I am 71 - I did not see the other proposals at the time but from what I have heard they could not match this one. My only hope and prayer is we do not have to erect any more of these. Paul Fitzgerald"

Friday, October 25 at 03:57 PM:
Joe De Feo from New York wrote:
"As deeply affected as anyone, I am happy to finally see suitable and worthy ideas begin to evolve. I love the celestial aspect of the project and the symbolism of the old observation deck height being observed. Bravo!"

Friday, October 25 at 03:13 PM:
Thea Volpe from Columbia U and Jersey City wrote:
"American Spirit Tower is the design to use! It captures so much of what I hoped for. As someone who escaped from the Path that day, and who is still recovering, I know I need a special place to remember and to look to the future."

Friday, October 25 at 02:13 PM:
Michael Jay from (citizen) wrote:
"It's great that your design includes the original cathedral-like column design, and two towers. I had thought that was the right thing for a memorial. However, I also think it should be a working building, as well, not just a viewing platform. Good work."

Friday, October 25 at 10:32 AM:
Mike M from Connecticut wrote:
"Best I've seen. Rising taller than the originals, and the tallest in the world symbolizing we've come back better than ever. The facades of the twin towers at the base, the diversity of the hall of heros, the elegant simplicity, this design has it all. Kudos!!"

Friday, October 25 at 09:49 AM:
William Heber from Torrance, Calif. wrote:
"I Think the Memorial Tower and reflecting pools make a beautiful memorial. My only suggestion would be to work with the other architects involved to design the business aspect. The four towers seem more like an afterthought. The perfect solution is to combine fabulous memorial design with forward looking and comprehensive redevelopement of not just the sight itself but the surrounding areas of lower manhattan."

Friday, October 25 at 09:31 AM:
Daniel Hall from Connecticut wrote:
"Awsome design. It should be done. Great job!!!"

Friday, October 25 at 09:13 AM:
Mike Schiraldi from 120th street wrote:
"Awesome. This is exactly what i was waiting for. Now make some better renderings; how am i supposed to drum up support from everyone i know when your pictures are so crude?"

Friday, October 25 at 08:47 AM:
Paul from Brooklyn, NY wrote:
"Thank you for finally coming up with the design that we were all waiting for. Once we cease to be enterprising and audacious, we cease to be Americans. If constructed, your tower will show the world that New York and America are strong and resurgent, while still providing a beautiful lasting memorial and a balm to the suffering of those who lost loved ones. One comment: I do hope that the office buildings in your design will prove less monotonous and more interesting than the boxes depicted. After all, this isn’t Albany!"

Friday, October 25 at 08:27 AM:
JOHN F BIGLEY JR from STRATFORD CT wrote:
"FINALLY SOMETHING TO PUT NEW YORK BACK ON TOP. WHAT BETTER WAY TO TELL THE TERROISTS. KNOCK IT (US)DOWN WE'LL BUILD IT BETTER AND TALLER. THE CANADIAN NATIONAL RAILWAY TOWER IN TORONTO IS 1800+ (1819 FT I THINK) SO SOMETHING OVER 2000 FT IS THE LEAST WE COULD DO FOR THOSE NEARLY 3000 PEOPLE WHO PERISHED. FROM AN ENGINNERING VIEW IT SHOULD BE APPROXIMATELY 1/2 OF A BUILDING WITH A TAPERED DESIGN TO AVOID A PANCAKE EFFECT SHOULD THIS EVER HAPPEN AGAIN. WITH THE UPPER 1/2 A SELF SUPPORTING STRUCTURE SIMILAR TO THE TORONTO STRUCTURE. THE LAST SEVERAL FEET WOULD BE FOR TRANSMISION OF RADIO AND TELEVISION SIGNALS AND SOME SORT OF PLATFORM FOR BOTH EXTERIOR AND INTERIOR OBSERVATORIES. IN MY OPINION THE MUSEUM SHOULD BE JUST BELOW THE OBSERVATORIES AND JUST ABOVE 2000 FT A SYMBOLIC GESTURE THAT WE ARE CLOSER TO THOSE MANY POOR SOULS THAT WENT TO THIER RESTING PLACE THAT DAY. WE REALLY NEED TO THINK WHY THOSE TOWERS WERE BUILT IN THE FIRST PLACE. YES THEY OBVIOUSLY PROVIDED OFFICE SPACE. BUT THEY WERE BUILT BECAUSE THE HUMAN SPIRIT AND MINDS WANTED TO DISPLAY GREATNESS. AND FOR 30 YEARS THEY REPRESENTED JUST THAT. NOW THAT THE SHOCK IS WEARING OFF. LET START REBUILDING THAT SPIRIT AND DISPLAYING WHAT WE AS A HUMAN RACE CAN DO. IN MY OPINION THE GENTLEMAN THAT SPENT THE $75,000 OF HIS MONEY TO DESIGN HIS IDEA IS DISPLAYING HIS SPIRIT AND DESIRE TO SHOW THOSE FEW RADICALS THAT THE MAJORITY WANT TO DISPLAY THEIR TRUE SPIRIT AND THEY WILL NOT DETER US IN THAT DREAM. I REALLY HOPE THAT WE DON'T FALL SHORT OF A DESIGN WITH HEIGHT. BECAUSE IF WE DO. THEN WE TELL THE RADICALS YOU WIN. SO HATS OFF TO THE GENTLEMAN I WOULD LOVE TO CORRESPOND WITH YOU AND IF THE STATION COULD FOWARD THIS TO HIM, THAT WOULD BE GREAT. THANKS FOR TAKING THE TIME TO READ THIS JOHN F BIGLEY JR. CERTIFIED RESIDENTIAL REAL ESTATE APPRAISER IN FARIFIELD COUNTY CT. AGE 41 WITH 2 KIDS. I WOULD LOVE T"

Friday, October 25 at 08:19 AM:
Don Ross Jr from Fairfield, CT wrote:
"To remember is to make alive by bringing to heart and to mind all we love. AST brings to heart and mind the best of what was - and gives the world hope of what can yet be. I hope AST comes to be."

Friday, October 25 at 08:15 AM:
Barry Mednick from Old Bridge, NJ wrote:
"This is THE one. "Lets roll""

Friday, October 25 at 07:27 AM:
R. Asquith McDonald II from Somerset NJ wrote:
"This concept is the first that I have seen presented that truly embodies what I believe is the sentiment of the City, and the Nation. New York City will always be incomplete until it has an imposing, grandiose, and magnificent Tower. What is Paris without the Eifel Tower? London without Big Ben? I could go on, but the point is clear. We cannot afford not to create something that will be not be on par visually with the twin towers. At the same time we do not wish to marginalize the feelings of the survivors of the victims of 9/11. This project nods at all interest groups, and I hope that it can be implemented sucessfully, and without delay."

Friday, October 25 at 07:16 AM:
Robert Metrey from Greenwich CT wrote:
"perfect!!! a fitting memorial"

Friday, October 25 at 07:05 AM:
Cynthia Marinese from New Jersey wrote:
"Magnificent! It is truly awe inspiring."

Friday, October 25 at 06:48 AM:
Amy from amcdonald@jenkens.com wrote:
"Surely this was inspiration!!! This is the best I've seen yet. I do hope the city goes along with this plan."

Friday, October 25 at 06:48 AM:
JOHN from NEW JERSEY wrote:
"I think that this idea is perfect! Good luck and I hope to see this beautiful tower built!!! Rudy once said..."it should be a soaring memorial...." the "American Spirit Tower" would be that!"

Friday, October 25 at 06:19 AM:
Alice Maalouf from White Plains, New York wrote:
"Your design is extraordinary. It captures the spirit of our city and the grief we feel for the loss of life."

Friday, October 25 at 05:36 AM:
Jeffrey Venturella from New Jersey, Birthplace: Bronx, New York City wrote:
"Heard about project on radio this morning. Of all the designs to date (though not many) this is the best - visually and from a hometown point of view..Pleasing to ones' memories. It will certainly fill the "gap" in the skyline for us. It will always serve as a visual arrow for where the disaster took place ( for those not familiar with the layout of New York City). If there is any problem with the families - it will be a pool buildt over the proverbial grave site of those not recovered. But the windstorm on the anniversary date - helped lift those spirits to a safer place. For me the pool is not a problem. Why not see if you can Implement the Globe from the origional "Square" and add a new "earth Sculpture" to the other pool. With the eternal flames at or above both. Most impressive is the height. Taller is better..and the observation deck being at the same height is Correct and Fitting of what once stood. The American Spirit Tower would indeed bring back what was lost and add a little bit more- visually and with alot of class. Amen "

Friday, October 25 at 05:04 AM:
Barbara from New York wrote:
"Very 21st Century and very impressive. I love the reflecting pools but in my opinion, it does not need to be so tall. Less is more. I hope this will be given serious consideration. It is worthy of it. "

Friday, October 25 at 04:56 AM:
Tim Fitz Maurice from Manasquan NJ wrote:
"The concept addresses all concerns, with dignity. It is an attractive, well thought out plan, and much better than anything else that has been proposed. The AST Tower is the way to go, no more wasted time, lets move forward. "

Friday, October 25 at 04:49 AM:
Peggy Kuhn from New Windsor, NY wrote:
"I think you AST Tower is beautiful. I especially like the "Hall of Heroes". Good Luck. "

Friday, October 25 at 04:41 AM:
Mike Niederer from Waretown N.J. 08758 wrote:
"What a wonderful and well concieved plan! Kudos to sir!"

Friday, October 25 at 04:40 AM:
Steven Pisani from Brookfield, CT wrote:
"Beautiful!--so much better than what has already been proposed. I have felt strongly for many months that the concept of reflecting pools on the towers' footprints would be perfect. The base of this tower is phenomenally evocative of the original architecture on the spot where it once existed. My only concerns are the enormous height exceeding that of the original towers and the fact that many groups want the former street grid to partially return--is that accounted for in this plan? "

Friday, October 25 at 04:03 AM:
Mary O'Donnell from Northport, NY wrote:
"Your design is simply awesome. I hope to see it come to fruition. I will pass along the information to as many people as I can."

Friday, October 25 at 03:35 AM:
Chet Cutick from Staten Island, NY wrote:
"The closest realization to what I think a memorial should look like. Simply excellent. My only question- are the office buildings in the background designed at the plain blocks shown? Or, are the views here just conceptual for placement and not an actual design?"

Friday, October 25 at 03:29 AM:
Thomas from Brooklyn (Greenpoint), NY wrote:
"This project is the best I've seen yet! Simple, symbolic and Solemn."

Friday, October 25 at 02:24 AM:
Walter Frey from Kings Park, NY wrote:
"I am a NYC police officer and have a deep bond with the former WTC. I think your idea is spectacular. I hope it comes to fruitation. New York needs a project like this. Best of luck!"

Wednesday, October 23 at 10:01 PM:
Bess Hinson from Frankfort, Kentucky wrote:
"This design serves many purposes. It fills the skyline--NYC needs to recognize its lost prescence. At the same time, the tower seems like a beacon of light and hope, while memoralizing the loss of life. Many plans have disappointed me. This one inspires me. "

Wednesday, October 23 at 08:05 PM:
Scott from NYC and New Haven, CT wrote:
"I was racing out of my hotel room the other morning when I happened to glance at the image in the NY Times ad. I stopped to read it and to look at the tower again, and again. I was amazed at how much you've blended and extended so elegantly and reverently. It's difficult to envision how to represent physically the emotions, themes and hopes of a memorial, especially this memorial, but it's easy to know when you've seen it. This tower engenders introspection of what and who we lost, admiration of the courage and compassion of what we saw and gave that unforgettable day, and inspiration for what we want New York and America to be for ourselves and for the world. To not build this would be a travesty. "

Wednesday, October 23 at 03:14 PM:
Dennis J. Doherty from djd@rumpuscat.com wrote:
"I came across your full page ad in the NY Times. Looks like the best design I have seen for the WTC site. I have your ad hanging on my office door here in Washington state for my co-workers to see. Good luck. "

Wednesday, October 23 at 11:39 AM:
Chester Burley from Maritime Trust Company wrote:
"Without doubt the best design plan/ concept I have seen for the WTC site. Congratulations and good luck."

Wednesday, October 23 at 10:17 AM:
Anthony Tobin from mail@anthonytobin.net wrote:
"I am very impressed with your project and hope it can come to fruition. It is a modern concept that retains important elements of the WTC."

Wednesday, October 23 at 07:17 AM:
Joep de Koning from Batavier1@aol.com wrote:
"I would like to meet with Mr. Russo privately to discuss the political and execution aspects surrounding the creation of the tower. A 30 to 60 minute meeting is envisaged. Joep de Koning "

Wednesday, October 23 at 06:49 AM:
Earle Robinson III from College Station, Tx wrote:
"I deeply appreciate the symbolism that has been put into the the design of the AST. The design is both simple and tasteful. I hope that this plan will go forward. Yo have my support. Earle"

Tuesday, October 22 at 10:22 PM:
Lawrence Russo from LMR@americanspirittower.org wrote:
"Mr. Davias, thank you for the post, your question has come up often. Transmission antennas are easily incorporated into the top part of the tower. They'd be positioned below the sky memorial, just inside the skin of the design (and would not be visible from the outside). thanks again, -Larry "

Tuesday, October 22 at 08:36 PM:
Michael Davias from Port Chester, NY wrote:
"The AST is stunning. I am already championing the concept with whoever will listen. I miss our twin towers. The skyline needs to be healed, but I am solidly against using those footprints for any commercial purpose. This design strikes the right chord with me. A suggestion: the tri-state area desperately needs a transmission tower to once again offer clear communications among our citizens, Could that be accomplished within this structure without destroying its unique symmetry?"

Tuesday, October 22 at 07:43 PM:
Scott K. Andrews, M.D. from NY, NY wrote:
" I saw the ad in the NYT and was overcome by its simplicity, beauty, and strength. I feel it is a fitting memorial and truly the best idea I have seen for the site to date -- impressive, as it should be, yet meaningful. I hope it comes to fruition."

Tuesday, October 22 at 03:17 PM:
Callie Cribley from Gainesville, VA wrote:
"I have seen some of the proposals for a memorial for Ground Zero and I have to tell you that this absolutely floors me to see this design it's definitly the one to be honoring and representing the fallen towers as well as all of it's victims who lost their lives on 9/11. It's structurally sound showing sheer strenght and it's towering height is a message to any nation/person that we can, will, and have risin above some of the most outrageous acts of terrorism in history and will continue to hold fast and strong to all that we believe in as a nation. God Bless to all those families who lost a loved one on 9/11 ... May God be with you forever! Much Love to All - "Nunc scio quit sit amor""

Tuesday, October 22 at 02:54 PM:
Larry Rubin from New York wrote:
"[accidentally hit the post button before finishing] An appropriate memorial to the victims of 9/11 should be AT LEAST"

Tuesday, October 22 at 02:53 PM:
Larry Rubin from New York wrote:
"Congratulation on the concept of the AST. The principle is sound: a memorial to the victims of 9/11 should be AT LEAST"

Tuesday, October 22 at 12:51 PM:
robin Gilbert from rgilbert@ibl.bm wrote:
"Hello, I saw your announcement in the NY Times of 10/10/02. I'm not an architect and knew of no way of passing along a thought about construction of a replacement to the WTC (or any tall buildings)until I saw your ad. This thought has to do with safety, after seeing the evacuation times taken by those lucky enough to get out of the WTC.I realise that others may have considered my suggestion but I feel happier getting it off my chest, so I can feel I've done my bit. If the fire department burn time allowance for floors and walls etc is say 1 hour this does not make sense if the evacuation time from the top floor, by stairwell, is say 2 hours given that the entire population of a building may be in the stairwell at the same time. The answer to this it seems (and your design is perfect for this, and its absence worries me) is to have crosswalks at different levels from building to building. These crosswalks could be open all the time for regular use or open only for emergency use. It then would not matter as much what the burn or evacuation time is, and these evacuation paths would offer another escape route should entire lower floors be unavailable. They would also allow quick evacuation to a smoke-free environment. The problem of evacuating the handicapped and injured is also made easier. I seem to recall that the evacuation time of a 747 jet is 90 seconds, achieved only because of the many exits available. Why not employ this theory to any building and have either (at least) two buildings built side-by-side or narrow escape towers on either side of a main building strong enough to withstand a sideways blast of WTC force? Sad reflection on our times. Hope you find this useful. Regards Robin Gilbert. rgilbert@ibl.bm p.s. Rescue services could also gain quicker access with these crosswalks.RG"

Tuesday, October 22 at 11:38 AM:
T. Nave from Encino, CA wrote:
"I love the idea of the tower and everything it represents. I think it is appropriate and very symbolic. The only comment I have is this. To replace the twin towers with something that structurally looks a lot thinner and narrow going up in a thin line makes the look like it got weaker. The structure should represent strength and energy. Although allthose elements are there and well thought of, from far it looks like a thin line going up in the sky. It does not compare to what was there before. We nWe need to have something stronger, more majestic and something that would showcase our country's everlasting power, our ongoing strength and that we are still standing. I would prefer to see what replaced the towers is a structure that is unbreakable, stronger and better than ever."

Tuesday, October 22 at 06:59 AM:
John McDonnell from Greenwich, CT wrote:
"It's difficult to put into words how much better the Tower is than the original 6 proposals. The office buildings leave something to be desired, but how many office buildings are really attractive anyway? One could think of them as the boring canvas upon which a beautiful work of art is drawn. On a practical front, I would recommend that part of the tower be used for antennas. They could be hidden behind fiberglass or something like that."

Monday, October 21 at 10:25 PM:
Annie Siegmann from Playa Del Rey, (LA) California wrote:
"Excellent. I will pass this on."

Monday, October 21 at 02:34 PM:
Jim Heatherly from Chelsea, New York wrote:
"The design of the Tower and use of reflecting pools both symbolic and appealing. However, the 4 banal glass boxes standing guard need to be rethought. This space needs thoughtful architecture, not boring boxes. Also, where is the Hotel space that is part of the Silverstein leases."

Monday, October 21 at 12:39 PM:
ALEX STARODUBTSEV from NEW YORK wrote:
"HI, I WOULD LIKE TO TELL THAT THIS PROJECT IS GREAT. IT IS INDEED SYMBOLIZE ALL WHAT SHOULD BE REMEMRED. IF I WILL HAVE A CHANCE TO VOTE FOR BEST PROJECT, IT WILL BE AMERICAN SPIRIT."

Monday, October 21 at 11:47 AM:
Peter Tse from New York wrote:
"Much Better than the original six designs. Were those designs done by architects or accountants?"

Monday, October 21 at 10:36 AM:
Joe Simeck from New York NY wrote:
"This is the most beautiful, fantastic, creative;(and most importantly); fitting MEMORIAL to all the "Heroes" of 09/11/01. It is my most sincere hope that this project will be the one to succeed and be built on the former World Trade Center site."

Monday, October 21 at 10:10 AM:
Joe Sticca from Joe Sticca wrote:
"Very cool "

Monday, October 21 at 10:02 AM:
Pedro Plumey from logunede806@aol.com wrote:
"I love the AST project. I believe that it is a wonder and beautiful tower that reflects both the pain that was felt on that day and the Holiness of the site. AST in my opion also show our readiness to enter the future with a new light, hope, and with more awareness of the events that are taking place in the world around us. AST is a beautiful symbol of the mordern change that we must undergo."

Monday, October 21 at 10:02 AM:
Pedro Plumey from logunede806@aol.com wrote:
"I love the AST project. I believe that it is a wonder and beautiful tower that reflects both the pain that was felt on that day and the Holiness of the site. AST in my opion also show our readiness to enter the future with a new light, hope, and with more awareness of the events that are taking place in the world around us. AST is a beautiful symbol of the mordern change that we must undergo."

Monday, October 21 at 07:33 AM:
john festa from new york city wrote:
"i absolutely love it. it is the only suggestion made that remembers and inspires. please make it happen."

Monday, October 21 at 05:54 AM:
David Peace from New York wrote:
"A great idea especially using the structural elements from the original towers as the base design, to remind people of what there was. However I don't like the 4 smaller towers, they are monotonous and too close together; some people would not get sunlight as they would be blocked by the next building. Also good to anchor the tower in the former footprints. Best idea so far for a memorial tower !"

Saturday, October 19 at 04:28 PM:
Todd W Thomas from Temecula, CA wrote:
"Outstanding idea, certainly worth great consideration. I believe the greatest memorial at this site would be a building grander than what was destroyed. You certainly are making an effort in that direction. I think your design is a little overdramatic in it's homage, but it reflects the times."

Saturday, October 19 at 01:08 PM:
rafi rubin from israel wrote:
"great idea, great plan.honoring the innocent victims and showing the world that nobody can murder liberty - at the same time, using nature (the sun) and the human abilities (AST - taller than any built structure), is the right solution to rebuild the WTC."

Saturday, October 19 at 03:18 AM:
andrew adney from sydney, australia wrote:
"The building is too tall. I like the concept of the top reflecting sunlight though. Buildings would be more appropriate for space utilization though not as tall as former WTC"

Friday, October 18 at 12:54 PM:
mario behar, new york, ny from http://mbehar.natureavenue.com wrote:
"I permit myself to enter again in the discussion (previously on Oct 14th) because of two reasons: 1) is the apparent BASIC DISCUSSION - Should the future Ground Zero be only a Memorial, or be both Memorial and have economic functionality; 2) is today's extensive "Idavidcooke" entry with which I agree ... I see many similarities of opinion w/ him/her, w/ the "year ago" idea he/she saw, and w/ the "americanspirittower" authors ... W/out imposing my idea as "the last word" (rather, to invoke some kind of intertwining of ideas) I invite people to see it at the address indicated next to my name above ..."

Friday, October 18 at 07:31 AM:
Randy from Randy wrote:
"This is a cool sight, While reading news online, I got the feeling of America Pride. The American Spirit Tower is like the Pheonix rising from the ashes, and the USofA will TOWER above all. GOD BLESS"

Friday, October 18 at 06:01 AM:
ldavidcooke from ldavidcooke@yahoo.com wrote:
"Just a thought. It would seem to be an advantage to build interconnecting twins. With towers this high, having a place to work for the salvation of a sister tower should be an important consideration. The images of people without a choice, especially the couples, was extremly heart wrenching. Unless the tower can be defensable history only stands to be repeated. I for one do not wish to stand by and watch that happen. Though I like the sweeping design and the Hall of Hero's, I think a modification to the basic design that is a little more failsafe is in order. It is interesting in that the tower has a definite Eiffel Tower flair, though this is NY not Paris. May I suggest an alternative? There was a design I saw several years ago that was based on an long range acoustical microphone. It looked kind of like a gattling gun with all the barrels pulled together. And each barrel was of a different length. With a fire fighting station on the roof of each "barrel" and an emergency egris from the roof of an adjacent higher roof to the lowerer roof offers a designed in alternate rescue platform. Plus if raised as translucent circular structures with a contrasting square base, with an original TWC facade, would be in line with the progression from the original "Box Towers" to the twin "Columns of Light". But hey, this is your design not mine! Great work on your conception! I like the illusion and the concept. I just do not think it representative of the occasion. My choice. Congratulations, L. David Cooke Wilkesboro, NC "

Thursday, October 17 at 04:28 PM:
Joshua T from Bergen County wrote:
"Sounds like a great concept on the drawing board. Who's gonna finance this? Larry Silverstien? Ultimately the final 10 designers are already chosen. This is a political and financial arena. "

Thursday, October 17 at 03:58 PM:
Alan Snedeker from Farmington, CT wrote:
"Best idea yet. A symbol. Simple. Congratulations"

Thursday, October 17 at 01:52 PM:
vangogh from amsterdam wrote:
"Is this simply a dream...or a reality?"

Wednesday, October 16 at 05:21 PM:
Lisa Flores from New York City wrote:
"To put it simply, the American Spirit Tower is beautiful. It is a memorial to those who died and suffered on September 11, 2001 and a celebration of the lives of the people of New York City. I used to work at 7 World Trade Center and I am in temporary office space still in the downtown area and will be moving to permanent space (again still downtown) sometime next year. I hope that one day I will see your Tower and reflect, remember and reconnect. Good luck."

Wednesday, October 16 at 05:21 PM:
Lisa Flores from New York City wrote:
"To put it simply, the American Spirit Tower is beautiful. It is a memorial to those who died and suffered on September 11, 2001 and a celebration of the lives of the people of New York City. I used to work at 7 World Trade Center and I am in temporary office space still in the downtown area and will be moving to permanent space (again still downtown) sometime next year. I hope that one day I will see your Tower and reflect, remember and reconnect. Good luck."

Wednesday, October 16 at 03:16 PM:
Angela Rodriguez from New York wrote:
"I love the project. "

Wednesday, October 16 at 02:40 PM:
Felipe from San FRan wrote:
"This design is amazing. I really like how the monument rises and soars from the original footprints. It kind of has elements of Sarrinen who designed the st louis arch. More creative solutions could be used for the 4 slabs meant to be commercial space. How about something circular surrounding it. Something..."

Wednesday, October 16 at 02:03 PM:
Carol O'Leary from Rye Beach NH wrote:
"Faith is the absence of fear. American Spirit Tower gives us all the ability to have faith."

Wednesday, October 16 at 12:32 PM:
Jason from Austin, TX wrote:
"Although the American Spirit Tower's height at 2200'is the highest structure ever to be erected, it will never adequately represent the height of the American Spirit. However, it is an excellent attempt. I will definitely contribute to help further the project."

Wednesday, October 16 at 12:04 PM:
Fred Smith NYC from NYC (Lawyer)-Part 2 wrote:
"After posting my comment I read down through a number of others' comments. It seems that most of the negative and ho-hum remarks are from people who don't know what it is to live inside Manhattan. I live in midtown, work downtown. Something magnificent has to be built in that aching hole in the earth. Aside from the grace of your design, I also want other readers to understand what it would mean to once again have a high monument there. Driving back to the city, the twin towers were visible from twenty miles away. A compass point for travelers, a way to glance at the skyline when in town and get oriented which way is South, an anchoring place for the spirit of New York. P.S., if some weirdos think it looks like an "obscene gesture," remember who it's intended for..."

Wednesday, October 16 at 11:53 AM:
Fred Smith from NYC (Lawyer) wrote:
"Excellent design idea. Best one I've seen. Perhaps a publicity campaign with the local media would cause the public to contribute toward a lobbying effort."

Wednesday, October 16 at 08:55 AM:
Jim Gearhard from Seattle, WA wrote:
"Beautiful! After 20yrs in the architectural profession, I don't think I've seen a more elegant, thoughtful and appropriate design ever proposed.... for ANY project. Simply lovely. I wish you the best of luck with this."

Wednesday, October 16 at 08:35 AM:
Paul Seaman from (Friend of Nicolas wrote:
"I believe the concept is beautiful, particularly the prism for lighting on the llth. That is truly brilliant; whatever concept is finally approved, I believe that should be part of it. That said, I believe that more consider- ation should be given to leasable space. I don't think that there is much chance of acceptance with no realty as part of the concept. I believe that real estate interests MUST be part of any successful solution. Sincerely, Paul G. Seaman"

Wednesday, October 16 at 08:35 AM:
Paul Seaman from (Friend of Nicolas wrote:
"I believe the concept is beautiful, particularly the prism for lighting on the llth. That is truly brilliant; whatever concept is finally approved, I believe that should be part of it. That said, I believe that more consider- ation should be given to leasable space. I don't think that there is much chance of acceptance with no realty as part of the concept. I believe that real estate interests MUST be part of any successful solution. Sincerely, Paul G. Seaman"

Wednesday, October 16 at 08:29 AM:
tony from nyc wrote:
"this represents the spirit of new york. bold-aggressive-unapologetic! that's right. when they knock down our towers we build bigger ones. for all of these clowns who feel that the entire area should be sacred, blah blah blah. the entire planet is practically a burial ground. people have died everywhere. you don't honor the spirit of the dead by accepting defeat. for all those not from nyc whith their 3 dollar comments, keep them to yourselves. you have know idea what it means to be a new yorker!"

Wednesday, October 16 at 08:22 AM:
td from nyc wrote:
"awesome-the best design yet"

Tuesday, October 15 at 07:57 PM:
All of you from gerrymig@aol.com wrote:
"I would like to see a full picture (as the NYT advertising) that shows the tower and a line showing the altitud of the Twin Towers. Clean, effective design. I go for it. I like the idea of the sun iluminating the names of the victims. Congratulations."

Tuesday, October 15 at 04:12 PM:
Alessandro from NYC wrote:
"awesome!!!"

Tuesday, October 15 at 02:56 PM:
DMC from Brooklyn NY wrote:
"This is it! I find your design to be simple and awesome, serene and magnificent, appropriate for a memorial and sufficient for commerce. What was lost on 9/11 will never be replaced, and the first thing we need to do is create a beautiful place where we can remember all of the lives that were taken that day. I have a beautiful, warm feeling when I look at these pictures. I wish you all the best with this design."

Tuesday, October 15 at 01:33 PM:
john doe from virginia wrote:
"OMG. lol it does look like an obscene gesture. Those 4 black monolith office buildings need to go!"

Tuesday, October 15 at 11:38 AM:
Rich Hermann from Illinois wrote:
"This is a Joke Right. Are we supposed to be building the worlds largest obscene gesture? Size doesn't count in monuments. "

Tuesday, October 15 at 09:39 AM:
Robert Tucson from Arizona wrote:
"I visited NY for first time in 1983 and remember my visit to the major NYC landmarks. Crossing the Lincoln tunnel and seeing the first glimspe of the mountainess skyline is a memory I wont forget. The attitude and style of New Yorkers was a close second. Reading these post I see some negative feedback regarding function versus form. Atleast these are the first concepts to offer something soaring and overreaching. I think that is why it's so hard to replace something that was monumental. As for the people who slam the concepts. Maybe people want "

Tuesday, October 15 at 12:16 AM:
Julie from Syracuse, N.Y. wrote:
"These people are absolutely nuts....I think a memorial for the victims is a wonderful idea but this is crazy!!!! A memorial should be a practical reminder of those we lost...this is NOT practical! Furthermore, I believe it serves as a constant reminder of those who are still suffering and grieving. Seeing this collossal monument would only bring them back to that terrible aftermath which I'm sure is the last thing they want to remember...And may I add one more thing since I'm being objective. Building this tower would only cause trouble with a capital T. What if those terrorists try to pull a fast one again and decide to hit it with one of our aircrafts full of passengers?? Would you now think it's the most beautiful inventive project known to man?? I think we should save our tax dollars and scrap this ridiculous idea..."

Monday, October 14 at 07:30 PM:
Gilbert Gjersvik from NYC wrote:
"If I stuck a fountain pen in some mud I guarantee that 99 percent of the people on this message board would have an orgasm. Gilbert"

Monday, October 14 at 06:52 PM:
Patrick Butler from Douglaston, NY wrote:
"It is pretty cool. I liked it. It's important to have a tall structure rather than a few shorter ones."

Monday, October 14 at 06:50 PM:
Julie A. butler from Queens, NY wrote:
"God, this is absolutely beautiful. I love it! The American Spirit Tower has everything we could hope for in a memorial. It will restore the skyline, recall the beauty and simplicity of the lost Towers, and honor those we lost in the most beautiful and meaningful way. "

Monday, October 14 at 06:23 PM:
julieg from chicago,il wrote:
"i am a New Yorker with a new address.i will always be a New Yorker no matter where i currently live.i think it looks nice but i really want the towers rebuilt. the skyline is New York. and we need to replace what was taken away. to let the world know we can take a punch and keep standing. we will not be cut down. we will stand larger then life. that is who we are!"

Monday, October 14 at 05:15 PM:
mario behar, new york, ny from mbehar7@earthlink.net wrote:
"Form & proportions of the tower itself and in relation to the environment are OK (!), but more functionality should be added to the tower ... 2200 feet of a structure will be too expensive to remain only a memorial, and more: What the perpetrators wanted was to kill the way of life the old towers were representing - their vitality! ... Communication & other scaled down services should be back w/out overshadowing the basic - memorial, purpose of the structure!"

Monday, October 14 at 01:29 PM:
robert r from wildheart02@aol.com wrote:
"This is the best concept I have seen thusfar. My only concern is that it should be bigger.(wider) the over all height is not necessary. Lights could be used for that at the observatory."

Monday, October 14 at 12:13 PM:
Mark Laubisch from Rochester, NY wrote:
"Best design I have seen so far. Other people in my office agree - best yet so far !! "

Monday, October 14 at 12:02 PM:
Paul Rees from Rapid City, SD. wrote:
"I like it. Very intresting design. "

Monday, October 14 at 11:42 AM:
Gary Willers from NYC wrote:
"It's true the masses are asses, I cannot believe all the positive comments this piece of crap is generating here."

Monday, October 14 at 09:08 AM:
Gustavo Ramos & Roger Gordon from Bob Altavilla Interiors wrote:
"Dear Lawrence and group, We're very impressed by your sensitivity to everything; the space, the form, the light, everything. The concept of using the sun, the inclusion of the pentagon, the respect shown to all of the heroes; it all adds up to a beautiful concept. Hoping your efforts will be fruitful. Thank you for an inspired and inspirational tribute."

Monday, October 14 at 08:50 AM:
Carl from Cheyenne, Wyoming wrote:
"I like the ideas, but honestly, it's a pretty ugly building... I do like the idea of being the tallest building in the world, reflecting pools, and the sun thing on 9-11 every year... "

Monday, October 14 at 08:46 AM:
Teresa Daniel from Phoenix, AZ wrote:
"This is a beautiful tribute to the heroes of 9/11. It evokes memories of the original towers and elicits a whole new feeling of wonder at how strong and resilient the people of New York and the United States are. I can't imagine a more fitting memorial. "

Monday, October 14 at 08:41 AM:
Fitz from stiftap productions wrote:
"awesome this is my choice for the design thanks guys this is awesome!"

Monday, October 14 at 08:26 AM:
Robert Nardi from Bay Ridge,N.Y. wrote:
"This is the best memorial plan I've seen. Incorporating the tallest structure ever built with the need to continue with commerce and respect towards all that has happened."

Monday, October 14 at 07:35 AM:
Mike Weinstein from Long Island, NY wrote:
"Congratulations on a superb design. Make it real. "

Monday, October 14 at 07:12 AM:
James Merkin from Manhattan wrote:
"Brilliant way of incorporating the Tower's footprints without building on them. I like the idea of small fountains in the pools. Also, what about some trees and/or flower grouves where people could sit quietly and think ? The open space could be used for public events. This tower is majestic without being intimidating. There is no reason for it to contain offices if that is taken care of by other buildings. "

Sunday, October 13 at 07:31 PM:
Nicole P from Queens,NY wrote:
"I heard about this project on NY1 and now that I have seen it for myself I feel it is a wonderful concept which ties everything in. We need a memorial and for the hallowed ground to be preserved, a peaceful place where people can come. The office and store space, antenna and transportation were all well thought out. I hope this project will be accepted by all and become a reality. Good luck."

Sunday, October 13 at 05:24 PM:
Tracy from Long Island wrote:
"I think your design is innovative and beautiful. It just feels right. I wish you lots of luck."

Sunday, October 13 at 05:02 PM:
Nick Pearson from NYC wrote:
"Great!! I hope we can all make it happen."

Sunday, October 13 at 05:02 PM:
Lorraine from NYC wrote:
"I love it! Soaring and dignified, the Tower would be an appropriate addition to the skyline, and a fitting memorial to what we lost on 9/11."

Sunday, October 13 at 09:52 AM:
Teresa. E. Bruns from Cleveland, OH wrote:
"The American Spirit Tower feels just right to me; I didn't think anything would. It puts the land to rest, provides a headstone worthy of the deceaseds' honor, and rises like an open hand to God. How can I help? "

Saturday, October 12 at 08:00 PM:
Lisa DiFilippo Raborn from NJ wrote:
"Interesting and dignified concept. Artist images are beautiful. Would there be any symbolic memorial for the Flight that went down in Pennsylvania?"

Saturday, October 12 at 07:13 PM:
Rabbi Ben Kamin from San Diego wrote:
"This idea, and the images, are actually as healing as they are soaring. Bravo! Everything about this project is right--the facade, the holy spaces, the recalling of the Twin Towers in the design, the yearning, surging beauty and might that truly restore both the skyline of that magnificent city and the soul of this beautiful nation. I pray that this comes to pass!"

Saturday, October 12 at 05:00 PM:
W. C. from Brooklyn wrote:
"I have not been very active in all of the memorials etc. surrounding 9/11. Of course like everyone else I feel deeply for those who sacrificed in any way especially through loss of life. I also feel for all Americans because we will in the wake of this tragic attack forever live life very differently. I have seen other proposed projects for the prior World Trade Center site and felt basically that they were over done-too bold-almost in the way that our enemies discribe us Americans. The American Spirit Tower, beginning with the name, is almost minimalistic by contrast. The gigantic structure gracefully soars in the air almost as if to ascend to heaven. the twisting base in oposition to traditionally huge rectangular mass calmly lifts ones spirit as if to allow for vicarious experience. The reflecting fountains are very clever. How better to recapture the world renown shape of the WTC? Without going on and on. I like the plan very much. Unfortunately, in the enviornment that we have entered, I'm concerned that such a beautiful site if built, will undoutedly be mared by repressive security; a sign of the times. "

Saturday, October 12 at 09:22 AM:
Donald Rosenfeld from from what? wrote:
"Plan is the best one yet- though, the tower should have 50 floors of office apace."

Saturday, October 12 at 09:09 AM:
Jim Roberts from NYC & New Jersey wrote:
"The concept of the tower & the preservation of the twin towers footprints is glorius, as is the design of the tower - the height & the observation decks - and the echo of the original design of the twin towers at the base. I think the design & integration of the office towers & the memorial museum need some rethinking; as structures, they seem to be afterthoughts unrelated to the reflecting pools & the tower. Overall, the concept is terrific! And the tower fills that terrible gap in the skyline beautifully. "

Saturday, October 12 at 07:17 AM:
David Park from New Canaan, CT wrote:
"Terrific concept. Definitely the best idea that I've seen so far. The use of the WTC facade as part of the design is ingenious. The top of the Sky Memorial reminds me of Lady Liberty's torch. Is this intentional? It's probably a shame that you have to include the commercial complex as part of the design due to commercial design constraints. I hope your design is implemented. I would support it fully."

Saturday, October 12 at 06:47 AM:
Joshua Sills from JoshStudio@compuserve.com wrote:
"Below is a copy of an email I sent to the LMDC on September 19th, before I had heard of this (or any similar) project: To Whom It May Concern: 1.) A memorial is desired for the World Trade Center site. 2.) A new radio/tv antenna is needed for the tri-state area. 3.) A need exists to create incentives to draw people to a functioning area, yet show reverence as well. My suggestion is to build a single large memorial tower, something like the Eiffel Tower, either over or very near to the footprints of the two trade center buildings. Underneath and around the tower should be landscaped parkland and public space. The tower itself should have freely accessable areas/viewing platforms and perhaps a restaurant. At the top of the tower, below the antennae, would be a private maintenance/control complex. The total height of the tower should be one foot for each of the 9/11 victims (including the antennae masts). The tower could have lighting incorporated into it that could either: a) mimic the blue beams of the earlier temporary memorial (an array in opposite legs?), or b)illuminate the structure itself like the Empire State building, or both. Office, residential, hotel, and cultural buildings could be built around the memorial area to truly make it another one of New York City's unique neighborhoods, with its own restaurants, cinemas, and other service establishments. This would add another icon to New York City that would draw world-wide recognition, yet also make an area that would be both sacred and vibrant at the same time. Signed, Joshua Sills 125 West 86th Street New York, N.Y. 10024 JoshStudio@compuserve.com 9/19/2002 "

Saturday, October 12 at 05:49 AM:
Lawrence Strumpf from Brockton MA wrote:
"I think this is doable as the TV tower that is proposed for Governor's Island. Building this on the WTC site would make a fitting memorial while satisfying the need for a tower like this within 3 miles of the WTC site."

Saturday, October 12 at 03:35 AM:
Gilbert Gjersvik from NYC wrote:
"I felt like I was driving into Vegas when they were shining those beams of light!"

Saturday, October 12 at 03:31 AM:
Jay T. weis from Paris France wrote:
"This is phenomenal. The same creativity and drive to produce this must be equally put forth in implementing its acceptance. Best of Luck."

Friday, October 11 at 11:55 PM:
Joe Doria from New York City wrote:
"I always thought the most beautiful tribute I would see about the WTC would be the "Beams of Light" I was hoping that when a memorial was built, they would somehow incorporate two powerful beams of light. When I saw your most maginficent tower, I was amazed. The prism that would be shown every year on September 11th would be the most beautiful memorial that not only NYC but our country would ever witness. I always believed that the beams of light would somehow make all the souls lost find their way home to their families. Your American Spirit Tower incoporates that. The City of New York should embrace this idea. This would be a wonderful tribute to all the children, parents, siblings, and spouses who lost someone they love. By building this tower I believe that the city of Manhattan would find its way to "heal" and will show the whole world that this city, is the most beautiful city in the world."

Friday, October 11 at 11:26 PM:
Lawrence Russo from LMR@AmericanSpiritTower.org wrote:
"We're working on an additional element of the tower and making renderings in the coming week. What would you think of the idea to put a light beacon at the top of the tower that will shine skyward at night? Or perhaps moving the eternal flame now in Battery Park to the top of the tower? tks, -Larry"

Friday, October 11 at 10:50 PM:
Irwin Luck from OPFD@hotmail.com wrote:
"The tower and the concept is absolutly befitting and architecturaly fantastic. I do hope that this is built. However, I do not think the 4 office buildings should look like boxes. There definitly should be a world trade center of office buildings that is as graceful and flowing in its architectural splendor as the tower that rises to the sky. "

Friday, October 11 at 09:51 PM:
frank porembka,jr. from 108 singer way ligonier,pa. 15658 wrote:
" the design is absolutely beautiful, meaningful, and functional. i sincerely hope that this proposal is accepted. it is a magnificent memorial to this unbelievable mega-tragedy."

Friday, October 11 at 06:54 PM:
Thomas Wall from New York City wrote:
"This design is absolutely the best presentation I've seen for the site. It is the perfect combination of reverence for the past and hope for the future. It's symbolism is graceful and not tacky, it's space is utility-oriented and not crammed full of junk, and you satisfy every conceivable group of people demanding a memorial, a park, office and retail space, a transportation hub, and all while leaving the footprints inviolable. The American Spirit Tower is inspired. Sincerely, best of luck with this project."

Friday, October 11 at 06:50 PM:
Monica & Tim from tmurphy1@stny.rr.com wrote:
"This has to be it. The multi-emotional and architectural dimensions say it all. A tribute to life and life memorial. The shape, the size,the pools, the names,the light... Good luck. "

Friday, October 11 at 04:33 PM:
Henry Kleiner from Kinnelon, NJ wrote:
"Absolutely wonderful design. Congratulations."

Friday, October 11 at 04:33 PM:
Henry Kleiner from Kinnelon, NJ wrote:
"Absolutely wonderful design. Congratulations."

Friday, October 11 at 02:36 PM:
Simone Schulz from Long Island wrote:
"I think your beautiful, simple and elegant design is exactly what the heart and mind needs! It far exceeds any of the previous plans submitted for the site. Please let me know how we can make it happen."

Friday, October 11 at 02:31 PM:
rob bookman from new york wrote:
"I have worked downtown in this area for 20 years and lived through 9/11. This concept is the best by far that I have seen. It meets every important criteria and would be a wonderful addition to NYC. Let's end the search, adopt this now, and start the rebuilding. The downtown retail scence will be a ghost town by the time a decision is made."

Friday, October 11 at 02:26 PM:
; from ; wrote:
";"

Friday, October 11 at 02:25 PM:
Leor from sflfb90@aol.com wrote:
"The American Spirit Tower was the best idea yet."

Friday, October 11 at 01:48 PM:
W Gray from NYC wrote:
"Nice thought behind all this-- but unfortunately, ugly as all get-out. When did Buck Rogers become an architect? Move over and provide some financing but let a real architect behind the wheel."

Friday, October 11 at 01:08 PM:
Peter Wade from pwade0429@hotmail.com wrote:
"As a close friend to several people we lost in the WTC, someone who worked downtown for 12 years and a lover of NYC, this proposal seems to the best of the bunch to date. It appears to meets the areas commerical needs while building a memorial that all New Yorkers can be proud to share. I particularly like using the same design as the WTC facade for the AST. I am not sure if it is anticipated in your design, but I would suggest burying West Street between Vesey St. and the Battery. Good luck!"

Friday, October 11 at 12:50 PM:
evelyn ellis from edellis46@email.msn.com wrote:
"Wow!"

Friday, October 11 at 12:16 PM:
Bob K from St Louis wrote:
"This is the best memorial / facility that I have seen. It is a good balance between functioning office space and making a very good statement. I feel it is right to go higher than the original towers, yet it would not create the associated problems with high rise office space. Weaving in a likeness to the original columns of the Trade Center is a very nice idea."

Friday, October 11 at 12:15 PM:
Elissa B. Elias from Cooper City, Florida wrote:
"Absolutely love the American Spirit Tower. It commemorates those lost on 9/11 as well as creating a beautiful tower with meaningful spiritual touches that will make it truely unique-like the New Yorkers/Americans that we are. This definitely gets my vote!"

Friday, October 11 at 12:11 PM:
Ellen T from Huntington, NY wrote:
"Now that's more like it - beautiful and elements of the original structure would fill the optical void. It should exist just as you propose. "

Friday, October 11 at 12:10 PM:
peter vairo from NYC wrote:
"I worked in the Trade Center and am a native NYer. I love this design. It has all the components needed for the area and the view will be awsome. Will there be an observation deck like the WTC had. That would be even better. "

Friday, October 11 at 11:47 AM:
rosa from california wrote:
"Go for it!"

Friday, October 11 at 11:46 AM:
AST designer(s) from J. Socha wrote:
"Several months ago, I witnessed plans through a contact of mine in Manhattan that addressed another tower with cabling that formed a spiraling pattern which served as a canopy to the park at ground level. It would be larger than the CN tower standing at 1850' tall with 4 buildings encircling it with glass-mirror-like interior facades. The holographic illusion that it created through some convoluted engineering scheme is something that you may be interested in tapping into. "

Friday, October 11 at 11:30 AM:
Paul J. Modarelli from Leonia, New Jersey wrote:
"The moment I saw your rendering in yesterday's New York Times I was inspired by the grandeur of your vision. This proposal is a most fitting and reverent tribute to the heroes and, yes, the American Spirit. To cower out of fear would be to give the terrorists another victory. I hope that it receives very serious consideration from the powers that be. "

Friday, October 11 at 10:46 AM:
Bill from New York City wrote:
"Inspired and inspirational!"

Friday, October 11 at 10:46 AM:
Steve Dreyer from Standard & Poor's (55 Water St.) wrote:
"This is the most inspired design I have seen yet. It does honor to the victims and meets the business requirements. Good luck!"

Friday, October 11 at 10:38 AM:
Kristan Tetens from East Lansing, Michigan wrote:
" How about adding a more explicit acknowledgment of the Flight 93 victims...perhaps the trees at the site could be trees replanted from Somerset County, Pennsylvania, or grown from cuttings of those trees."

Friday, October 11 at 10:38 AM:
Great Job! from Esteban from Miami Beach wrote:
"Congratulations for a job well done! I love the proposal, its conception and aesthetics. And the way it is presented here. Good luck, I hope it is chosen! "

Friday, October 11 at 10:27 AM:
George Sparacino from Hazlet, NJ wrote:
"I'm glad you aimed for something grand and were not intimidated. It's respectful of those who were murdered by the terrorist animals, yet not afraid to stand tall for the whole world to see. Good job. I hope it's chosen. I was at ground zero at 8:46 AM on the 11th of September. "

Friday, October 11 at 10:21 AM:
David from New York wrote:
"It's like God came down from the heavens and said, " If you can dream it, you can build it." This is clearly a wonderful well thought out project, especially the prism effect. It gets my vote and hopefully the rest of the world agrees."

Friday, October 11 at 10:01 AM:
Jim Yost from Manhattan wrote:
"Fantastic. What a wonderful design and idea. It would be an excellent memorial to the victims of 9/11 and a dramitic way to restore the NYC skyline. "

Friday, October 11 at 09:56 AM:
David D. from Minneapolis, MN wrote:
"I was immediately captivated by the raw symbolism this memorial projects. "

Friday, October 11 at 09:53 AM:
Christine from St. Louis, MO wrote:
"This is truly one of the greatest pieces of conceptual architecture I have ever seen. Having seen/visited Ground Zero, this site absolutely needs a memorial such as yours. The reflecting pools and having the new tower "grow" from them is brilliant and emotionally symbolic . . . The Hall of Heroes is breathtaking as well. Please, keep up the fight and let all of us who support you know what we can do to help you get this idea to the forefront!"

Friday, October 11 at 09:37 AM:
Heinz Verhaegh from Tenafly, NJ wrote:
"Love it!"

Friday, October 11 at 09:37 AM:
Richard Hartbeck from St. Louis, MO wrote:
"Most dramatic and beautiful use of the site I have ever seen. Hope this gets built."

Friday, October 11 at 09:27 AM:
Valentin Sazhin from Brooklyn, NY wrote:
"American Spirit Tower is clearly the best WTC site project among those presented to public. My family and all co-workers of Lodestar International Tours are voting for this wonderful project. Sazhin family - 4 people Lodestar International Tours staff - 20 people."

Friday, October 11 at 09:04 AM:
Mike from Buffalo wrote:
"I think this is the best design I have seen. Truly stunning. I love the concepts intigrated into the design of the reflecting pools in the footprint of the former towers, the mirror reflection of the former facade, the sunlight of 9/11 and the memorial and office space. It would be an awsome sight in the NYC skyline and an inspiring memorial."

Friday, October 11 at 08:52 AM:
ron allen from new york city wrote:
"Love your design, hope it is considered."

Friday, October 11 at 08:41 AM:
Marian S. Marschall from scrimshaw@juno.com wrote:
"This is the most inspiring idea for a memorial yet. I love every aspect. It should be adopted in it's entirety and implemented right away. There is no need for any more design competitions."

Friday, October 11 at 08:34 AM:
Dave & Karen Allan from Houston, Texas wrote:
"We think this whole concept is stunningly beautiful and truly inspirational!!!!!! You guys have such nifty ideas, especially the prism at the top of the Tower. Who do we have to contact to put in our vote for going ahead with this project?"

Friday, October 11 at 08:02 AM:
Steven Rivellino from New York City wrote:
"Bravo! Finally, someone has designed the first truly magnificent structure for the 21st century! I have always believed that the memorial for the WTC victims should be in the sky; I have always believed that the strongest tribute should be in light... a perenial torch, atop the world's tallest tower, burning always. The Captain of the QE2 told me recently that the light at the top of the WTC was the first thing he'd see as the ship made her approach towards New York harbor, and now that light has been extinguished. Your spectacular, intelligent, moving design will give a new light to the world in a fitting yet practical tribute to that remarkable place. I support you 100%. Let's just make this happen... stevenrivellino@aol.com "

Friday, October 11 at 08:00 AM:
khondoker hossain from 43 38 judge st.apt 1fl elmhurst ny 11373 wrote:
"i like this monument ,this is really beautiful .and i believe that would be the real spirit for us.so many thanks to that designer and those people who are helping to build this one."

Friday, October 11 at 07:56 AM:
NYC Resident from Manhattan wrote:
"expected, boring, unispired. But I guess you guys are rich and can do whatever you want too. Hey I have an idea before designing a building for the world to see why don't you try having you know, an idea."

Friday, October 11 at 07:55 AM:
Kathleen Peer from kpeer@privateconsulting.com wrote:
"I think this is a wonderful idea! The tower captures the spirit of the original Twin Towers. Incorporating the design elements of the WTC in the base of the tower at the reflecting pool is very moving. I hope you can convince others to move forward with this."

Friday, October 11 at 07:12 AM:
mdv713@hotmail.com from ocean grove,nj wrote:
"Great idea ! Please push this idea through the red tape."

Friday, October 11 at 07:08 AM:
Michael Brown Jr from michael@macny.com wrote:
"Love the basic design of AST. Saw an ad in the New York Times. Well done guys. What needs to be done now to get this to happen. Michael B"

Friday, October 11 at 07:00 AM:
Laura Guerrero from El Paso, TX wrote:
"I am impresssed with the feeling the Spirit Tower gave me upon viewing the images on the internet. What a great way to honor all the fallen hereos, victims and their families. To see the Spirit Tower standing would be a strong message to all that we Americans can rebuild and stand as tall as those towers in spirit. "

Friday, October 11 at 06:58 AM:
kyle bright from joliet, il wrote:
"Case closed. Period!"

Friday, October 11 at 06:17 AM:
Kerry Recker from St. Louis, MO wrote:
"My first reaction when I heard about it was negative....some grandiose scheme just to build another "taller than any other" structure. But now that I see it I like the idea, it's beautiful in it's simplicity."

Friday, October 11 at 06:15 AM:
Anna Rodriguez from San Antonio wrote:
"What a magnificent structure! As a New Yorker myself, I would feel very proud to showcase this memorial to the world!!!"

Friday, October 11 at 05:53 AM:
Randy A. Kleinheider from Missouri wrote:
"Absolutely wonderful concept!! Great incorporation of the Twin Tower footprint and Pentagon into the design! This would be a perfect tribute, memorial and statement."

Friday, October 11 at 05:52 AM:
Sandra Recker from St. Louis, Missouri wrote:
"The architecture and design are supurb. Excellent concept. By far, better than anything else I have seen suggested. My concerns would be a) does the office space replace the office space lost in the destruction? and b) do you have any idea of the cost for the entire project and who will pay for it? "

Friday, October 11 at 05:32 AM:
Lawrence Russo from LMR@AmericanSpiritTower.org wrote:
"Janice, it's interesting that you brought up the item of the steel structure that was removed. I had just been thinking that perhaps it could be incorporated somewhere on the park grounds. Likely near the Hall of Heroes. I think it's great that so many ideas are coming from this website. I'm open to anything that can add to the design concept in a way that is respectful to the memory of those that were taken from us. What has to get done first is to let the powers that be (Mayor, Governor, LMDC) know that this project has the support of the people. I am very grateful for all the very kind messages on this board (even some of the not so kind ones). Please write the Mayor and the LMDC and let them know your thoughts as well. Thank you all, Larry Russo"

Friday, October 11 at 05:28 AM:
Michael Peter Basssock from Farmington CT. 06032 wrote:
"This would be one of the most creative memorials I have seen to date to honor the victims and heroes of 9/11. I have worked in the financial industry for many years and on Wall St. for some of those years. This would not only be a wonderful tribute to the "fallen" but a statement to the world that we do not forget! Go for it!"

Friday, October 11 at 04:20 AM:
Janice Cagan-Teuber from Arlington Heights, Massachusetts wrote:
"I like the concept, however, the view of the complex, "head-on" looks remarkably like the buildings are forming an obscene gesture. I'm sorry to say that, but that was my first thought. Was that intentional on the designer's part? Was it subconscious? I wonder if there is a way to vary the heights of the office buildings, so as to lesson that image. The concept of the tower, though, is impressive. What about the steel structure that was removed from the remnants of the original towers? Will that be part of the AST? Part of the park? I believe that also needs to be incorporated into whatever memorial is constructed. Thank you. Janice Cagan-Teuber "

Friday, October 11 at 02:06 AM:
marcello from italy wrote:
"great project !!!! But new york also need hight skyscraper as Chicago,Hong Kong and Shangai I love new york more than ever. good bless america Marcello Lazzaroni"

Thursday, October 10 at 09:43 PM:
Brian Dodge from La Mesa, CA wrote:
"I think it is the perfect balance of everything this site should become. I've felt there was too much 'lost' with the other proposals. The re-use of part of the same design the original buildings had can help us cling to what once was... that we may never forget! And, recreating a dramatic punctuation in the skyline as it does, gives it the presence it has earned and, now, deserves. In short, it is absolutely perfect."

Thursday, October 10 at 09:06 PM:
AnDrew McKenzie from Oxford, Ohio wrote:
"This concept appeals to me far more than other proposals I've seen for redeveloping the site, and I know I'm not alone. By combining a stunningly beautiful memorial with office real estate, it can serve the practical and emotional needs of so many."

Thursday, October 10 at 08:25 PM:
Sherine Tully from Seattle, WA wrote:
"The first word that comes to my mind is: FABULOUS!!!!!! It is a project that is elegantly and respectfully responsive to the site and to the event of 9/11. It is both sombre and uplifting. You have captured the painful history and yet you have also transcended that and turned the building into an icon of hope for the future. You should be very proud of this work. Thank you."

Thursday, October 10 at 07:23 PM:
Bob Moran from North Bergen, NJ wrote:
"So far, this is the most impressive idea I've seen for the former WTC site. My office is located nearby and I would be most pleased to look out my window and see this beautiful structure that commemorates the tragedy and those people whose lives were lost that day while at the same time echoing the prior structure. I hope it gets the nod from the "powers that be.""

Thursday, October 10 at 06:59 PM:
Abraham Ruiz from New York City wrote:
"This is an amazingly beautiful, compassionate and inspirational design. You honor the innocent souls of September 11, with grace, strength and dignity. It is by far the most thought provoking and enlighting design for the sacred ground on which I hope, you will build. "

Thursday, October 10 at 06:58 PM:
Gerard Cortinez from Greenwich Village NY wrote:
"Thank you so much for this inspired plan. Wonderfully designed and presented, this is the first concrete idea I have seen which truly captures the American spirit to move ahead--stronger and more humane after the terrible events of last year. We need to remember but also celebrate the lives lost as well as the best of human nature which came shining forth through the darkness. Please let us know how we can support this project to help it become a reality. Are there specific ideas yet about the memorials to the individuals lost? Perhaps an interactive multimedia piece would work nicely. Best of Luck--and remember no one design will ever please everyone. Hold true to your vision! "

Thursday, October 10 at 06:55 PM:
AST Team from Rich Moccia NYC wrote:
"As a native New Yorker this is the only design so far offered that makes any sense and hopes satisfies everyone. I truly like the idea of the "taller tower" height. Fear must not get in the way of the beauty of tall towers/structures and still having the greatest skyline in the world! Good Luck! "

Thursday, October 10 at 06:48 PM:
Brett and William Knight from NYC wrote:
"This is the most creative, sensitive, inspiring and encompassing design. We were extremely moved by the symbolic relavance of the concept including: -The preseravation of the footprints with reflecting pools -The incorperation of the original face design -The equal height of the first observation dect to that of the original towers -The ambitious attempt to go to a greater height, which is symbolic of the spirit to rise above -The use of a sun lit memorial We hope your proposal moves the decision makers as much as it moved us. Best of luck!"

Thursday, October 10 at 06:48 PM:
Walt Ricker from Somerset, NJ wrote:
"At last a plan with imagination, creativity and memorable. What the site needs is something immediately identifiable - like the st. Louis Arch, he Eiffel Tower, the old WTC we learned to love, and still miss"

Thursday, October 10 at 06:48 PM:
Gilbert Gjersvik from NYC wrote:
"Hey Lawrence, I'm impressed, you get a slightly critical comment and next thing you know the guy's mother comes on here to apologize for him. Here's another critical comment, this one from me: Will people have a time limit for their somber reflection at the top of the tower, and what is your anticipated hourly capacity. Given the extraordinary enthusiasm this memorial is generating on this message board, I anticipate very, very long lines. Maybe there could be something like at Disney where the crowds are entertained while they wait? Gilbert"

Thursday, October 10 at 06:43 PM:
Bill Brent from Portland, Oregon wrote:
"I'm afraid I can't support your American Spirit Tower. I don't think it captures the American Spirit at all. What makes America different, what sets America apart from every other country is her spirit of free enterprise, and opportunity for all. It's what immigrants the world over seek when they come here. It's what the terrorists hate and what they tried to destroy. I do not believe that your concept captures the heroism and determination of the American Spirit. Rather, enshrines a permanent sadness, a broken spirit."

Thursday, October 10 at 06:33 PM:
Mrs. Faulkner from Christopher's mother wrote:
"I must apologize for my obviously retarded son's highly inappropriate comments regarding your most wonderful and impressive site. Not only does this appear well thought out, but it is creative,concise, elegant, and to the point."

Thursday, October 10 at 06:33 PM:
Mr. & Mrs. Martin H. Mohr from Hackensack, NJ wrote:
"Just viewed the American Spirit Tower...in today's issue of the New York Times. Your idea s absolutely fantastic...you did not forget anyone or anything. It certainly would be the most beautiful memorial site. We do not have to look at any other design...you have done it all! Good luck! "

Thursday, October 10 at 06:27 PM:
Darryl P. Benjamin II from Yonkers, NY wrote:
"I think this is a great design full of vision, compassion, and the TRUE American spirit. It is inspirational and awe-inspiring. I believe that NYC should have a distinct skyline which was lost on 9/11. If we are going to rebuild it should be the tallest structure in the world;any less would not be NYC. This is a great replacement for the magnificent World Trade Center. I also beleive that the observation decks are a great idea. The facade design is also great to keep the memory of the twin towers. I will also be sending my thoughts to the LMDC and Larryl Silverstein as well. Thank you for trying to maintain the spirit of NYC and the entire nation. Darryl Benjamin II dbenjaminii@aol.com"

Thursday, October 10 at 06:11 PM:
F. Alvarado from New York wrote:
"i think that this is the most beautiful archictectural idea that ive seen to memorialize those who will remain in our hearts; its simplicity and elegance would definitely represent our city. The idea of the two pools stemming from the footprints of the wtc is wonderful and the tranquility of having a park is also beautiful, simple and respectful... In hope that this idea comes to fruition... thank you. "

Thursday, October 10 at 06:03 PM:
Syed M Abidi from Staten Island wrote:
"This is gorgeous and an Eye catching Design. Unique and gracefull ! A true homeage to our heroes. I truly hope and pray you win this design. Good Luck..."

Thursday, October 10 at 06:02 PM:
Carmine Fazzari from Carmine F wrote:
"Dear Mr. Russo: Gorgeous! Stunning! Your design struck a chord no other design has been able to do. I still feel that we need to put the towers back, maybe adjacent to the original sites, and definately taller. But we live in an age of conservatives who lack the boldness the original planners had. Anything less that what we had reeks of capitulation. I'm glad to see you've developed something so special. Only critique - Those four buildings at the north end of the complex need to be spectacular. Make 'em look like the orginal towers maybe? Or make them symbolize the NYPD, the FDNY, The PAPD and the EMS workers. Best of luck, sir. Sincerely, Carmine Fazzari "

Thursday, October 10 at 06:01 PM:
C. DelBuono from NYC wrote:
"Out of all the proposals I've seen, this is the best and makes the most sense as a memorial and for businesses. I hope this happens."

Thursday, October 10 at 06:01 PM:
Rickey Shaum from Dallas, Tx wrote:
"Incredible! This gorgeous building took my breath away - something a building has not done in years. I think it is a perfect tribute to those we lost and miss so dearly, the past twin towers (an architectural marvel for the time), and of course to the future; announcing that life does go on! From the souful reflecting pools, imitating the past two towers, to the ingenious use of natural, God given light to shine upon the names of those still living in our hearts. Go American Spirit Tower! - Let's roll!"

Thursday, October 10 at 06:00 PM:
H Cefrey from New York wrote:
"You have made, by far, the best design idea. I had thought of the Eiffel Tower, or something like it. Your design is stunning and perfect. Not only does it represent the American spirit, but it represents a global recognition, as we lost many of those who come to America to build within a global community. The reflective pools in the footprints are a touch of pure genius. It will be a design of great discussion and analysis for all time. Your idea is simply, wonderful. I hope (and pray) that it comes to fruition."

Thursday, October 10 at 05:55 PM:
Jodi Molisani from Middletown, NJ wrote:
"I saw the ad in the NY TImes today and had to e-mail you. What an incredible idea! I especially love the illumination by the sun on the names every 9/11. I wish you the best of luck and I would be delighted if your idea became a reality. "

Thursday, October 10 at 05:26 PM:
Jennifer Bidwell from Royal Oak, Michigan wrote:
"I saw your ad in the NY Times today. After having seen the earlier six proposals and reading the ideas being bantered about, I believe your design has captured what we need at the WTC site perfectly. It is simple, beautiful, graceful, and full of reverence. I love the way it reaches into the sky and towers over the skyline. I vote overwhelmingly for your project. "

Thursday, October 10 at 05:22 PM:
Dan Cunningham from Boston, MA wrote:
"Excellent work. I like the recognition of our Pentagon losses as well. "

Thursday, October 10 at 05:11 PM:
Rev. John Dietrich from Mt. St. Mary's Seminary, Emmitsburg, MD wrote:
"I just saw your Tower in the NY Times. Instantly I thought that this is the best design thus far on what should be done with the World Trade Center site. Congratulations! I only hope the Tower becomes a reality. God bless. Fr. Dietrich"

Thursday, October 10 at 05:00 PM:
Richard William Cooke from Deerfield Beach FL wrote:
"Wonderful! Beautiful! Majestic! Powerful! Overwhelming! Awe inspiring!Exactly the kind of creative, aggressive, forward-thinking, risk-taking, bold design we who are hurting so much need! Restore the majesty and greatness and soaring spirit of the NYC skyline. Anything less will not do at all!"

Thursday, October 10 at 04:43 PM:
Dale Alan Zurbrick from retired teacher from Glen Cove, L.I. wrote:
"I saw this site in today's NYTimes....lost a former student and a current student's father in the disaster--college friend Renee Fleming sang at the first memorial service--I was privileged to attend that...and was deeply moved, as I'm sure I will be again if THIS idea is the chosen solution. You have my support. (current SUNY Potsdam Alumni President)"

Thursday, October 10 at 04:39 PM:
Carol Ann from San Francisco wrote:
"I think it's atrocious, it looks like a missle or a riffel, leave the complexs take away the tall structure. It's not the size of our buildings that keep us strong and alive. The people who parished will always be remembered in our hearts and in the Hall of Heroes. "

Thursday, October 10 at 04:23 PM:
Michelle Smith from Kennett, Missouri wrote:
"Brilliant idea and design. I too know Mr. Russo and can assure you that this very kind, gentle, and unselfish man is motivated by love for his fellow man and pride in his country. Best of luck in the competition."

Thursday, October 10 at 04:10 PM:
Gilbert Gjersvik from NYC wrote:
"Calder, It has already been called "A morbid waste of urban space!" You'll have to think of something original, also taken are: A pathetic result of mindlessness. Stupid, yet tasteless. One word: Pathetic. In a word: sucks. I could email you even more if you'd like. All the best, Gilbert"

Thursday, October 10 at 04:06 PM:
Michael Calder from Boynton Beach, Florida wrote:
"Mr Gjersvik, your plan is morbid and does not hold a candle to the American Spirit Tower, and no, I'm not a relative or acquaintence of the designers."

Thursday, October 10 at 03:56 PM:
Gilbert Gjersvik from NYC wrote:
"Two comments: Where does the line of people form for the elevator ride to the top; Does the sun really shine from the exact same angle every 9/11 or would the platform rotate and rock to achieve the right angle? Other than that, I don't think the city needs its own space needle. If you're curious, this is a suggestion I've been pushing forward and currently appears on New York Magazine's Web site: http://boards.newyorkmetro.com/zerothread?id=9 All the best, Gilbert "

Thursday, October 10 at 03:37 PM:
Michael Calder from Boynton Beach, FL wrote:
"I love this plan! It's the best one I've seen to date. I hope it gets built and I hope you pass on my comments to those in a position to make a final decision."

Thursday, October 10 at 03:15 PM:
Michael Herrington from Miami Beach, FL wrote:
"I think this is a most inspiring concept and would like to see this be the final project. It makes an especially striking skyline, while honoring those lost and adding needed retail and office space. Good luck!"

Thursday, October 10 at 03:12 PM:
Bob from db2guru@aol.com wrote:
"This is by far the best design I have seen yet. This New Yorker thanks you!"

Thursday, October 10 at 03:12 PM:
Gary M. King from Brooklyn, NY wrote:
"Since the six mediocre Port Authority plans were unveiled in June 2002, I have been trying to describe to friends what I thought would be a fitting memorial - one that in some way restores the New York City skyline, pays tribute to those lost, and honors those who worked at the site for nearly a year after the attacks. In one fell swoop, your absolutely BRILLIANT design captures everything I would want to see in the site - soaring restoration of the skyline, a memorial, the preservation of the WTC tower footprints, a museum, etc. It is doubly brilliant to also pay tribute to the Pentagon disaster as well. I sincerely hope your design moves from Internet proposal & NY Times advertisement to reality. BRAVO!"

Thursday, October 10 at 03:06 PM:
Richard from NYC wrote:
"Absolutely stunning!! And I agree with the majority of comments that it is the best, simple, and most stirringly beautiful design I've seen to date. The original facade being incorporated is not "facile" as one person mentioned, it's a stroke of genius---considering it rises on the original footprint and is enhanced by the gentleness and drama of the reflecting pools. We need a taller-than-tall structure here (not another office building) and this speaks to that with elegance. As a Battery Park City resident, living in the shadow of the AST would be wonderful. (That said, I do think the office complex is realistic nor representative of the commercial needs of the neighborhood) But the tower should definitely be completed!"

Thursday, October 10 at 03:01 PM:
kemp mooney from atlanta wrote:
"In the rush to make individual expressions; it is shameful that such mediocre designs are brought forward. Levi may be an architect but this design denies his ability to create meaningful architecture. Hopefully this will not be a lasting proposal."

Thursday, October 10 at 02:38 PM:
Brad Smith from Washington, D.C. wrote:
"Saw your ad in the New York Times. This seems like a wonderful memorial; best of luck in winning the design competition."

Thursday, October 10 at 02:34 PM:
Tom Malone from Minneapolis, MN wrote:
"I think that this is a well thought out plan. Many have worried about the height issue but as far as I see, no one would want to plan a terrorist attack on a large statue with few people in it. As I look at the object it appears to be somewhat like the CN Tower in Toronto. There are not a whole lot of people to kill in such a tower. I thank this keeps American pride yet regards safety at the same time. -Excellent job!!!!!!!!!- "

Thursday, October 10 at 02:28 PM:
john tucker from greenwich village wrote:
"I like it a lot better than any of the port authority's previous designs. Still has a ways to go, but lots of good ideas "

Thursday, October 10 at 02:26 PM:
Donald Lay from Darien, CT wrote:
"I love your design especially the Sky Memorial and hope it receives serious consideration for adoption. I was most pleased to see that your design preserves the original footprint of the World Trade Center including the height of the towers. Best of Luck."

Thursday, October 10 at 02:22 PM:
linda from linda wrote:
"love it "

Thursday, October 10 at 02:21 PM:
Adam Jaffe from Leonia, NJ wrote:
"This is the best plan for the site I have seen. I hope it gets built."

Thursday, October 10 at 02:15 PM:
Avak O. Hasratian from Brown University wrote:
"This plan is beautiful and bold. Since it incorporates so many forms: the towers, their reflection, their shadow, their height, the pentagon, a museum, a memorial, office space, a park, it is the best and most ambitious plan I've seen to date, and I do hope it will be built! Carry on! Avak O. Hasratian Graduate Student Department of English Brown University"

Thursday, October 10 at 01:56 PM:
Russell Williams from 100 John Street wrote:
"I think your idea is the best I have seen. From day 1 I thought that there should be a memorial tower, not another high office tower. I love the fact that you incorporate the exterior of the original buildings and the height. "

Thursday, October 10 at 01:51 PM:
A. L. Dennison from a.l.dennison@asu.edu wrote:
"Congratulations on a bold and beautiful proposal. I hope it gets the serious consideration it deserves."

Thursday, October 10 at 01:50 PM:
Casey Strange from NJ wrote:
"It is perfect...We need to get this done."

Thursday, October 10 at 01:36 PM:
Danny from NY wrote:
"This idea is awsome! It would be beautiful. I hope it happens."

Thursday, October 10 at 01:34 PM:
Leigh Kelley from Richmond Virginia wrote:
"I think that the American Spirit Tower is a great idea. The only change I would make, is to make the office buildings a little taller, so that they stand out a little more in the New York City skyline."

Thursday, October 10 at 01:33 PM:
CM from Jacksonville FL wrote:
"Saw the photo in the NY Times and rushed right online. This concept is exactly the kind of thing that keeps the rest of the country in love with New York--bold, elegant, outrageous, thrilling, unique-on-the-planet. It's just what makes us long for our next visit to your city."

Thursday, October 10 at 01:21 PM:
Al Ridolfo from Greenwich Village,, NY, NY wrote:
"I love your idea for the WTC site. I wached the events of 9/11 with horror from the corner of 6th Ave and Washington Place in the village. This idea provides a fitting memorial, a skyline addition to replace what was lost, and the office, retail and hotel space lost in a very comforting way. When built it will give us a new anchor to the island and provide a fitting memorial to those we lost (including my friend Frank). "

Thursday, October 10 at 01:15 PM:
bgaither@gaither-proprietary.com from Brian Gaither wrote:
"This is horrid!!! The City skyline should not be dominated by something that does nothing. What you propose would turn the WTC site into some sort of perpetual graveyard with a tall, ugly tombstone. People marvel at NYC not because it is a collection of big buildings thrown up to decorate a long skinny island, but because it is a living, thriving metropolis. Your concept places too much emphasis on memorializing rather than where it should be placed--on renewing. Please don't pursue this idea. "

Thursday, October 10 at 01:05 PM:
Robert Tol from La Mesa, CA wrote:
"Interesting concept. I just couldn't figure out why you took out a full page ad in the NY Times."

Thursday, October 10 at 12:59 PM:
Sarah from Dallas wrote:
" I just had to say, since the question came up, that I happen to know Mr. Russo through a mutual friend, and I can only assure you that there is nothing other than a selfless and beautiful inspiration behind this project. I don't know whether New Yorkers will want the design to be implemented or not, but I know that Mr. Russo is trying this for the right reasons. The friend we share is a discreet person, but what he did tell me of Larry's reasons for attempting this project left me speechless on the phone the other night. Please believe that, even though it can be hard to have faith in people you've never met with the world in the state it's in. God bless-- Sarah"

Thursday, October 10 at 12:44 PM:
Arizonan from GDUB wrote:
"Although I live in AZ, I don’t believe there is anyone person who can honestly say that there life was not somehow affected. Quite frankly, I believe we should re-build the towers as they where, only bigger and bolder, to show American resolve. I like your idea, but why give credit were none is deserved. More over, I know I learned something, let’s move on!! "

Thursday, October 10 at 12:33 PM:
Willard L. Rose, Jr. from Century 21 Weber & Rose Realty wrote:
"This is a fantastic design and embodies the phoenix like spirit of New Yorkers! I sincerely hope that The Aamerican Spirit Tower design is selected for the WTC site."

Thursday, October 10 at 12:30 PM:
Donald Keppler from New York wrote:
"I find your proposal spectacularly simplistic and inappropriate for that site."

Thursday, October 10 at 12:10 PM:
Caitlin from CT wrote:
"I think the reflecting pools in the "footprints" of the original towers is an absolutely brilliant idea. I simply love that image and consider it my favorite commemorative part of the American Spirit Tower."

Thursday, October 10 at 12:00 PM:
Roni from Chelsea,NYC wrote:
"This is most impressive and beautiful design we've seen yet. It's magnificient and sacred at the same time. Send these posts to the redevelopment organizers so they give you their blessing on this practical, creative and most importantly meaningful design."

Thursday, October 10 at 11:50 AM:
Lawrence Russo from LMR@AmericanSpiritTower.org wrote:
"I had to respond to this. If you don't like the design, Mr. Faulkner, I can do nothing but respect your opinion. However, why you need to question my motivation is an issue only within yourself. I believe I've made my thoughts quite clear. Many of us have been affected by the events of September 11th in very dramatic ways. I would think you might understand that sometimes people do things just because they feel it's the right thing to do. Perhaps they feel a need to contribute. As for your question of why do I "push" my vision now, quite simply, it is because it is now that it is ready. I have been developing this plan for over 8 months. Forgive me, but I must say that I find your inference quite offensive. "

Thursday, October 10 at 11:49 AM:
American Spirit Tower from Chas Miller, Heather Maloney, Laura Hunt wrote:
"Three of us here at our office LOVE your design.... it's beautiful and your attention to every detail is exquisite. Save our skyline! GOOD LUCK"

Thursday, October 10 at 11:45 AM:
Max from New York wrote:
"This idea is fantastic. I love the simplicity of the site, unlike the complex proposals of other architects. Please push this idea to the correct athorities. Furthermore, I suggest putting out more ads or even better, commercials, to attract a wider audience to this magnificent idea. Good luck!"

Thursday, October 10 at 11:34 AM:
Cynthia Isom from Delaware Investments wrote:
"I like your proposal - especially the Sky Memorial."

Thursday, October 10 at 11:27 AM:
Mr. Russo from Christopher Faulkner wrote:
"All well and good. I question your motivation. There is a design process on going as well you know with special attention paid to the victims families. If your motivation is pure, why push your vision now?"

Thursday, October 10 at 11:27 AM:
John Delaney NY City wrote:
"I saw your full page ad in today's New York Times and was intrigued by this proposal's elegance and simplicity. In two minutes time, I was sold on the idea. I think this plan finds the correct balance between memorializing an unprecedented tragedy, and reaching for the clouds in a fashion befitting not only New York, but the United States as well. Let the phoenix rise. "

Thursday, October 10 at 11:26 AM:
jill brody from born and raised nyc wrote:
"It's a really wonderful design, both peaceful, respectful and useable. But I do wonder about the height. Is it necessary to have it so much taller than everything else around it? Because while all else in this design speaks of democracy and diversity and the melding of so many into a unified whole, the building itself has more egotism in it than I think benefits your overall concept. The idea of the annual illumination is brilliant --in every way. Jill Brody"

Thursday, October 10 at 11:14 AM:
LH from NYC wrote:
"I really like the idea of the American Spirit Tower. It is elegant, yet modern and while it is futuristic, it isn't disgustingly gaudy (like some other WTC memorial ideas I've seen). Very classy -- a nice way to memorialize the tragedy of Sept. 11."

Thursday, October 10 at 11:07 AM:
Kristan Tetens from East Lansing, Michigan wrote:
" I saw your full-page ad in today's New York Times and felt compelled to tell you how much I love the American Spirit Tower proposal. I gasped when I saw it, and tears sprang to my eyes. It is beautiful and elegant, aspiring and inspiring. I particularly like the Sky Memorial and the use of WTC facade details at the base of the tower. I'm glad that the design preserves the WTC footprint and marks the height of the original towers. I was in NYC for a week in January to help with the recovery effort, and your design captures perfectly the indomitable spirit of the city that I saw. Good luck! I hope your design becomes a reality. "

Thursday, October 10 at 11:07 AM:
Douglas from New York City wrote:
"You have got to be kidding. "

Thursday, October 10 at 10:52 AM:
Robert O'Connor from Connecticut wrote:
"I think this project would be a great anchor for the newly rebuilt lower Manhattan site."

Thursday, October 10 at 10:51 AM:
Angel Fernandez from Seattle,Wa. wrote:
"I am an Architect in Seattle. I work for Anshen + Allen. This is exactly what I had invision for this site. I am a little concerned of the height, but it is very elegant."

Thursday, October 10 at 10:48 AM:
Chris Berresford from Manhattan wrote:
"The office towers are boring and ugly! Make their design a bit more creative."

Thursday, October 10 at 10:34 AM:
Bertil Forsberg from Bertil Forsberg wrote:
"I love this design. It incorporates my wish to rebuild a striking tower at least as tall as the original and leaves the "footprints" as a memorial. Wonderful. "

Thursday, October 10 at 10:33 AM:
Gary from New York wrote:
"There are few things more dangerous than a crackpot with money."

Thursday, October 10 at 10:29 AM:
Adrian Zink from Lawrence, KS wrote:
"This is the best design for a memorial I've seen yet. The way the towers come together is symbolic of national unity, and the height-going above the original two is amazing. This project would be amazing if adopted!"

Thursday, October 10 at 10:21 AM:
Stephen Stratico from Merrick Long Island, New York wrote:
"Best design yet proposed. I hope your concept is selected and developed. Good Luck"

Thursday, October 10 at 10:18 AM:
jon blunk from Chicago wrote:
"Best proposal I have viewed thus far. Suggestion-make the office building circular vs. rectangular."

Thursday, October 10 at 10:08 AM:
Abigail Raymond Salaway from Malibu, CA wrote:
"This is a wonderful solution that pays tribute to the events of 9/11 while retaining the area as a vital, operational part of our great city. You have provided significant space for offices and commercial/retail space at one end; an inspirational tower repeating Yamaguchi's original tower design elements; an archive and memorial hall; and lots of clean open space with reflection pools. This would do it for me, thank you for sharing the plan in the New York Times. Abigail Salaway Third generation New Yorker, born, raised, and lived in manhattan for 40 years; recently exiled to the left coast. "

Thursday, October 10 at 10:08 AM:
Ricardo J Sales from Mexico wrote:
"The tower is magnificent. It is beautifully conceived and a structure worth sitting on ground zero. My only concern is that a tall structure sitting on ground zero is an obvious target for the loony tunes of the world. Specially the thin structure proposed. Security reasons might be an impediment"

Thursday, October 10 at 10:06 AM:
Victor Crozzoli from New York City wrote:
"Stunning.....and all encompassing. A tribute to those who perished. Practical, yet architecturally dramatic, it serves as an alternate to the now unlikely restoration of the original towers."

Thursday, October 10 at 10:04 AM:
kinnan o'connell from larchmont, ny (suburb of NYC) wrote:
"This plan has many inspired features: the use of reflecting pools in the footprints, the honor guard of four office buildings, the use of the same facade structure, the element of lighting - all are beautifully entwined. It wasn't until I reached the skyline views that I became afraid of the possibility of another plane crashing into the tower. The night view looks especially dangerous. I assume you have thought of this and have planned for this possibility. "

Thursday, October 10 at 10:03 AM:
jim clark 973-379-1927 from lost brother tommy on 9/11 wrote:
"none of the designs so far has caught my eye. they all seemed fine. this is superior to everything. so well done in every way. knowing i could always point to the tower in the sky to remind us of all our lost friends. i hope this works out. good luck."

Thursday, October 10 at 09:59 AM:
Dr. A. Mintez from Calfornia wrote:
"I have seen a number of these projects,and this one is the most stunning of all.It seems to encapsulate all of the important values and issues one could wish for. The art director did a wonderful job. The park and even the'sun beam'on 9-11 are just brilliant thoughts. "

Thursday, October 10 at 09:51 AM:
Jeffrey Zisselman from NYC wrote:
"Awesome. Memorializes the events which transpired and erects a structure showing the strength of America. At the same time there is still 9 million square feet of office space."

Thursday, October 10 at 09:46 AM:
Maxwell W. Hudgins, Jr. from Washington, DC wrote:
"Magnificent. I hope it will be built."

Thursday, October 10 at 09:26 AM:
Seeminly the Right Balance from Matthew George wrote:
"Finally...the first design which seems to strike the right tone from a memorial/contemplative perspective, but which is also addresses the commercial needs of downtown New York. Love the blending of pieces of the orginal WTC design with newer elements."

Thursday, October 10 at 09:22 AM:
Kevin Lapczynski from Central New Jersey wrote:
"I am very impressed. This has got to be the concept I've seen yet. Great work and good luck on your proposal."

Thursday, October 10 at 09:16 AM:
James Scantling from Hartford, CT wrote:
"The design of the tower is magnificent and perfectly captures the feelings that, I assume, most want - remembrance, strength, courage and optimism."

Thursday, October 10 at 09:10 AM:
F. Avellino from Hackensack, NJ wrote:
"This is an exceptional design, incorporating tribute, spirit and hope in a monument of graceful pride. I know I'd be moved and inspired each time I'd see this standing in New York City. Excellent idea of honoring the Pentagon disaster as well. "

Thursday, October 10 at 09:02 AM:
Russell from NYC wrote:
"These designs are appalling. The ideas and sentiments behind them are trite, simplistic, and phony as can be. This does nothing to meet the real needs of this city for its culture, its residents, or its businesses. "

Thursday, October 10 at 08:51 AM:
S. Hess from Hackensack, NJ wrote:
"This is, by far, the BEST idea I have seen for the site!! It is simple, yet majestic. It memorializes the past yet looks to the future. I sincerely hope that this plan becomes a reality."

Thursday, October 10 at 08:46 AM:
JK from 34th and Park wrote:
"I generally like the idea -- it definitely is bold and imaginative enough to be among the few designs worth considering. The world-record height and sky memorial are excellent elements. My only worry is that a spindly tower is not truly representative of New York City's architecture. It would need more puissance to completely convince me."

Thursday, October 10 at 08:37 AM:
Phyllis Gertzis from New York City wrote:
" I would hope that one of the memorial buildings will enclose the remains that cannot be identified and identified as the unknown. there should be a place within that memorial for a common religious altar where services wcould be held . it should also incorporate a place for the religious Jewish 'watchers' who are required by Judaic law to keep watch over Jewish remains until they ae buried. or perhaps that would be considered burial and the watchers would not be required.The design of the area pleases me both emotionally and esthetically and I would do whatever i could to further the project. i lost no one (actually one second cousin who i did not know)but every person who died was my family and I want to see them properly memoria.ized. Your project seems to do that. i congratulate you and encourge you. Thank you."

Thursday, October 10 at 08:34 AM:
Brian from brian_wood@eudoramail.com wrote:
"I think this is the best design I've seen. It incorporates the memorial and use of the space very well. It is very innovative, and the sun lighting on 9/11 is an excellent idea. Great job!"

Thursday, October 10 at 08:34 AM:
Jerry A. McCoy from Silver Spring, MD wrote:
"I think this is a VERY interesting concept. I greatly admire that the footprints of the WTC towers have been memorialized. The overall concept is reminiscent of Frank Lloyd Wright's "Mile High" tower. Thank you for doing this."

Thursday, October 10 at 08:31 AM:
amanda farinacci from ny1news wrote:
"Hey...I saw the full-page ad in the NYT and I am wondering why we have never heard from you guys before. Please call me 212-379-3356 or email amanda.farinacci@ny1news.com; I am a segment producer for NY1 and would love to hear about the idea. Amanda Farinacci"

Thursday, October 10 at 08:27 AM:
Craig Brown from cabrown@u.washington.edu wrote:
"LOVE THE TOWER IDEA, FANTASTIC Personally, I think there should be a water element included. Like 2900 (dont know the exact #) of six inch little fountains across a pond. It wouldn't be as hard or take up as much space as it might sound if separated by only six inches."

Thursday, October 10 at 08:25 AM:
Craig Singer from My2Centences wrote:
"I am a NJ filmmaker whose office is based in Tribeca...at first look, I think you have done an admirable job. Simple, distinctive but with a sense of majestry and meaningful power. Bravo & good luck. Regards, Craig A. Singer 212 966-0602"

Thursday, October 10 at 08:13 AM:
edward mansfield from washington, d.c. wrote:
"outstanding, absolutely outstanding. good for you guys and thanks. ed"

Thursday, October 10 at 08:03 AM:
Peter Hoffman from Chatham, NJ wrote:
"Congratulations on a beautiful design! Clearly the best one I've seen so far. Moving in its simplicity, yet the way the memorial soars into the sky, it sends a powerful message that our way of life cannot be defeated. This has the potential to become a landmark as beloved as the Statue of Liberty, and is a totally dignified and appropriate way to memorialize the events of Sept. 11. Best of luck."

Thursday, October 10 at 07:53 AM:
Tim Kelly from Calabasas, Ca. wrote:
"This is the first idea I've seen that replaces the Twin Towers without rebuilding them. Bravo! It is a beautiful and inspiring plan, that gives the New York skyline its dignity back, appropriately honors our fallen heroes, and meets all the commercial needs with buildings people will actually be comfortable working in. You have successfully bridged the gap between remembering the past, and looking into the future, with the indomitable optimism of the American people that makes this the greatest nation on earth. You have my full support. Sincerely, Tim Kelly Calabasas, Ca. "

Thursday, October 10 at 07:44 AM:
Ralph Loffredo from loffredorj@aol.com GV NYC wrote:
"Wonderful concept and execution. The tower and reflecting pools offer a perfect balance of grandeur and respect and pure NY audacity.The four rectangular background buildings, however, should be equally architecturally imaginativeand significant, something like the Eisenman concept published in the Sunday Times Magazine. Or something reminiscent of ruins from which the tower rises."

Thursday, October 10 at 07:43 AM:
Anil Aggarwal from San Ramon, California wrote:
"This is the finest plan I have seen so far. It is a true represention of American ingenuinity. It is bold and imaginative, inspiring, unique, timeless, and very clever as well - accomodates all constinuencies very well."

Thursday, October 10 at 07:27 AM:
Jon Belisonzi from jbelisonzi@aol.com wrote:
"I like it. How about two towers-same shape as your example. I want to see them as I,m travelling north on the N.J. turnpile coming up from Phila. I really miss seeing the orginial twin towers. Thank you for doing this."

Thursday, October 10 at 07:17 AM:
Rodrigo Berengia from Art Box wrote:
"I am sorry to say that after seeing the full page image in the NY Times, the design appears terribly simplistic, particularly the open areas between the tower and the perimeter edges. Also questionable is the incorporation of Yamaguchi's original base configuration. This seems overly facile. While I laud the attempt to honor the memory of the tragic loss of life I do not think this proposal really holds up. "

Thursday, October 10 at 06:59 AM:
Michael J. Castellano from Guilford CT wrote:
"The American Spirit Tower answers the concerns of all. It is: proud and humble powerful and sensitive outgoing and introspective commercial and memorial grand and personal forward and remembering nurturing and defiant it is our past, present and future. It is America at its best. IT IS NEW YORK ! B U I L D I T !!!!!! Michael J. Castellano Guilford CT (G-Z volunteer)"

Thursday, October 10 at 06:45 AM:
David Hartnett from Carteret,NJ wrote:
" This is the best and most inspiring plans I have seen. I used to work across from Tower 2 for twenty years, and very attached to the area. I was blown away from seeing the page in the New York Times this morning."

Thursday, October 10 at 06:42 AM:
Anna Maria Bastone from U.S. Customs Service wrote:
"Dear Sir/Madam: I am a WTC survivor who worked at U.S. Customs located at 6 WTC. I am now working in New Jersey, but miss New York terribly. Unfortunately, it doesn't look like we will be going back to New York anytime soon. I was reading the New York Times this morning and came across your American Spirit Tower Project and was immediately drawn to the picture. I am extremely impressed with your model and hope that it will win the contract. We who have survived, and sometimes forgotten, still feel the pain of that day. Therefore, when I looked at your picture, it seemed to cover all bases. Not too tall buildings, yet respecting our heros and building something tall to show the world that we are still standing tall. Thank you for showing me the possible future of what I used to call home. I will be retiring in seven years, so I may never see a "Customhouse" back in lower Manhattan, but someday I will go back and visit an old friend that I used to go home. Thank You and God Bless You. Sincerely, Anna Maria Bastone (home) - AnRia06@aol.com (work) - Anna.Maria.Bastone@customs.treas.gov "

Thursday, October 10 at 06:09 AM:
Leonard F. Lesser, Esq. from Goodwin Procter LLP wrote:
"Very impressive. Your ad in the NYTimes was simple and to the point; you let your visionary design speak for itself. Please let me know if I can lend any support. "

Thursday, October 10 at 06:00 AM:
William F. Mullin from New York City wrote:
"I would like to commend you on what is the most inspiring design to date for a memorial. I hope this reaches a realty. "

Thursday, October 10 at 05:51 AM:
Lawrence Goodwin from New York, NY wrote:
"Outstanding! I hope it happens."

Thursday, October 10 at 05:15 AM:
Robert Draizen from New York wrote:
"This is the most exciting version of any design proposed for the WTC site. From our apartment window we use to see the top 60 floors of the towers this would be a very welcomed replacement for the hole in the sky of lower NY. Please keep us informed of your developments. "

Thursday, October 10 at 04:59 AM:
Raul Parra from Florida wrote:
"I think this would be perfect. Have some of the old tower in the new. "

Thursday, October 10 at 04:46 AM:
Franklin R. Kaiman from Scarsdale/New York City wrote:
"I think the proposal is beautiful. I long have felt that there should be reflecting pools on the footprints. I like the concept of a memorial tower -- no commercial use -- rising out of the footprints. However, there should be no concession stands within the tower. It seems to me that nothing could be sold that wouldn't cheapen the site. Also I question whether the tower is too tall -- but I like it conceptually. Finally, I think the firefighters memorial (the one that was on its way to Missouri and was "donated" to the City should be a permanent part of any site."

Thursday, October 10 at 04:37 AM:
Maureen & Kevin McShea from Cornwall, NY wrote:
"We absolutely love the proposal. It fills the hole in our hearts more than any other plan we have seen and it helps to restore our NYC skyline. It shows love and respect for those who perished, but also the unbowed resolve of the American people. Good luck! "

Thursday, October 10 at 04:34 AM:
Tim Deluca from USA wrote:
"i love this idea is it really going to happen or is this just an idea? "

Thursday, October 10 at 04:30 AM:
Nick Alexos from Madison Dearborn Partners wrote:
"I admire your forwardness and ideas. How do you make your plans more relevant to the process?"

Thursday, October 10 at 03:53 AM:
Angelo from Boston wrote:
"Is it the Tower going to be used also as an Antena? On the "Hall the Fame" should also include the names of the people who helped on the rescue and still alive. A person does not have to die to be a hero!!!"